Witches Mini and Reuben Costello had their powers revoked by the witches' council as punishment for a crime Reuben committed against mortals. Now they must live as mortals themselves--and that means getting a job to pay the bills. A dating service is looking for a happily married couple to screen potential clients, and the Costellos jump at the opportunity. After all, over two hundred years of marriage make them more than qualified...

Holly Wentworth, the owner of the Romance Connection, is dedicated to helping others find the loves of their lives. When a handsome widower enters her office, she cannot deny the attraction between them, but she is unwilling to pursue a relationship with a client. It's up to the Costellos to bring the matchmaker a match of her own. They may no longer wield magic--but they've still got a few tricks up their sleeves...