Disc 1
- America (West Side Story) - Leonard Bernstein - Johnny Green - Irwin Kostal - Rita Moreno - Sid Ramin - Stephen Sondheim
- Tonight (West Side Story) - Leonard Bernstein - Max Goberman - Larry Kert - Irwin Kostal - Carol Lawrence - Goddard Lieberson - Sid Ramin - Stephen Sondheim
- Somewhere (West Side Story) - Leonard Bernstein - Jim Bryant - Johnny Green - Irwin Kostal - Marni Nixon - Sid Ramin - Stephen Sondheim
- Everything's Coming Up Roses (Gypsy) - Robert Ginzler - Goddard Lieberson - Ethel Merman - Sid Ramin - Milton Rosenstock - Stephen Sondheim - Jule Styne
- You Gotta Have a Gimmick (Gypsy) - Faith Dane - Chotzi Foley - Robert Ginzler - Maria Karnilova - Goddard Lieberson - Sid Ramin - Milton Rosenstock - Stephen Sondheim - Jule Styne
- Comedy Tonight (A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum) - Jason Alexander - William David Brohn - Paul Gemignani - Sid Ramin - Jay David Saks - Stephen Sondheim
- Anyone Can Whistle (Anyone Can Whistle) - Herbert Greene - Goddard Lieberson - Teo Macero - Lee Remick - Stephen Sondheim - Don Walker
- Everybody Says Don't (Anyone Can Whistle) - Herbert Greene - Harry Guardino - Goddard Lieberson - Teo Macero - Stephen Sondheim - Don Walker
- Do I Hear a Waltz? (Do I Hear a Waltz?) - Elizabeth Allen - Ralph Burns - Frederick Dvonch - Goddard Lieberson - Richard Rodgers - Stephen Sondheim
- I Remember (Evening Primrose (Mandy Patinkin's Dress Casual)) - Steven Epstein - Paul Gemignani - Bernadette Peters - Stephen Sondheim
- Another Hundred People (Company) - Harold Hastings - Pamela Myers - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- The Ladies Who Lunch (Company) - Harold Hastings - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Elaine Stritch - Jonathan Tunick
- Being Alive (Company) - Harold Hastings - Dean Jones - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
Disc 2
- Broadway Baby (Follies in Concert) - Paul Gemignani - New York Philharmonic - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Elaine Stritch - Jonathan Tunick
- I'm Still Here (Follies in Concert) - Carol Burnett - Paul Gemignani - New York Philharmonic - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- Losing My Mind (Follies in Concert) - Barbara Cook - Paul Gemignani - New York Philharmonic - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- A Weekend in the Country (A Little Night Music) - Harold Hastings - Goddard Lieberson - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- Send In the Clowns (A Little Night Music) - Harold Hastings - Glynis Johns - Goddard Lieberson - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- Pretty Lady (Pacific Overtures) - Timm Fujii - Paul Gemignani - Patrick Kinser-Lau - Jay David Saks - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Mark Hsu Syers - Jonathan Tunick
- Pretty Women (Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street) - Len Cariou - Victor Garber - Paul Gemignani - Edmund Lyndeck - Jay David Saks - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- A Little Priest (Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street) - Len Cariou - Paul Gemignani - Angela Lansbury - Jay David Saks - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- Not a Day Goes By (Merrily We Roll Along (Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall)) - American Theatre Orchestra - Paul Gemignani - Bernadette Peters - Jay David Saks - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- Old Friends (Merrily We Roll Along) - Paul Gemignani - Ann Morrison - Lonny Price - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick - Jim Walton
- Sunday (Sunday in the Park with George) - Paul Gemignani - Mandy Patinkin - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Michael Starobin
- Move On (Sunday in the Park with George) - Paul Gemignani - Mandy Patinkin - Bernadette Peters - Thomas Z. Shepard - Stephen Sondheim - Michael Starobin
- Agony (Into the Woods) - Paul Gemignani - Jay David Saks - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick - Chuck Wagner - Robert Westenberg
- Finale: Children Will Listen (Into the Woods) - Paul Gemignani - Bernadette Peters - Jay David Saks - Stephen Sondheim - Jonathan Tunick
- Dick Tracy : Sooner or Later (Sondheim - A Celebration at Carnegie Hall) - American Theatre Orchestra - Paul Gemignani - Jay David Saks - Don Sebesky - Stephen Sondheim - Karen Ziemba
- Unworthy of Your Love (Assassins (Original Off-Broadway Cast Recording)) - Paul Gemignani - Greg Germann - Annie Golden - Jay David Saks - Stephen Sondheim - Michael Starobin
- Loving You (Passion (Color and Light - Jazz Sketches on Sondheim)) - Brian Blade - Peabo Bryson - Oscar Castro-Neves - Miles Goodman - Christian McBride - Brad Mehldau - Stephen Sondheim - Nancy Wilson