Against Essentialism: A Theory of Culture and Society

by Stephan Fuchs

Overview

Against Essentialism presents a sociological theory of culture. This interdisciplinary and foundational work deals with basic issues common to current debates in social theory, including society, culture, meaning, truth, and communication. Stephan Fuchs argues that many mysteries about these concepts lose their mysteriousness when dynamic variations are introduced.

Fuchs proposes a theory of culture and society that merges two core traditions—American network theory and European (Luhmannian) systems theory. His book distinguishes four major types of social "observers"—encounters, groups, organizations, and networks. Society takes place in these four modes of association. Each generates levels of observation linked with each other into a "culture"—the unity of these observations.

Against Essentialism presents a groundbreaking new approach to the construction of society, culture, and personhood. The book invites both social scientists and philosophers to see what happens when essentialism is abandoned.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780674015968
Publisher:	Harvard University Press
Publication date:	02/01/2005
Edition description:	New Edition
Pages:	398
Sales rank:	734,262
Product dimensions:	5.75(w) x 8.94(h) x 1.00(d)

About the Author

Stephan Fuchs is Associate Professor of Sociology, University of Virginia.

Table of Contents

Introduction

1 Theory after Essentialism

Accounting for the Observer

Observing Observers

Levels of Observing

Ideological Conflicts in Observation

Inside and Outside Observers

Value-Freedom and Disinterestedness

The Myth of "Going Native"

A Few Pretty Old Rules of Method

The Classics Revisited, Briefly

Networks and Systems

Some Elements of a Working Epistemology

2 How to Sociologize with a Hammer

The Crisis of Representation

Underdetermination and Theory-Ladenness

The Indeterminacy of Translation

Empiricizing Contexts and Demarcations

Incommensurability

The Double Hermeneutic

Things and Persons

3 Cultural Rationality

After Reason

Causes and Reasons

The Unity of Persons

What Do Persons Want and Believe?

Decisions, Decisions

How to Locate Rationality

Some Covariates of Rationality

4 Foundations of Culture

Never Minds

Who Knows? No Idea!

The Meanings of Meaning

Observing Culture and Cultural Observers

What Is in a Culture?

Cultural Stratification

Art

Reputation

From Creativity to Genius

5 Modes of Social Association I: Encounters, Groups, and Organizations

The Bodies and Brains of Persons

Emotional Selves

Levels of Society

Encounters

Groups

Organizations

Variations in Organizational Cultures

6 Modes of Social Association II: Networks

Drift

Fields of Forces

Power to the Networks

Metabolism

Renormalization

Autopoiesis

Self-Similarity

Unity

Boundaries

Network Expansions

Networks of Culture

7 Realism Explained

A Continuum of Realism

Core Expansions and Time

Machines

Instruction

Density

Monopoly and Hegemony

Competition and Decentralization

Literacy and Printing

Orality, Perception, and Copresence

Consensus

Distance and Frontstages

Conclusion

Appendix: Theses

References

Index

What People are Saying About This

Karin Knorr Cetina

Against Essentialism presents the most diversified and extensive discussion of anti-essentialism I am aware of, bringing together a host of arguments that one usually does not find in a single volume. Fuchs lifts network theory out of its usual organizational sociological, economic sociology, and exchange theory context, and transforms it into a more constructionist and reflexive sociological theoretical framework that also manages to pay attention to microsociological dynamics. It is an original and scholarly contribution to social science theory.
— Karin Knorr Cetina, Bielefeld University

Mark A. Schneider

Against Essentialism is a brilliant book. Like certain martial artists, Fuchs uses the strengths of his enemies to confound them. Against post-modernists who view the social constructedness of culture as reason to abandon the substantive goals of old-fashioned sociological positivism, Fuchs deploys an even more thoroughgoing constructivism to re-envision as sociological variables the issues in dispute between constructivists and positivists. This is a stunning achievement. I can't think of a book whose publication I would more eagerly anticipate...and as much for the controversy it will create as for its contribution to the discipline.
— Mark A. Schneider, Southern Illinois University

Thomas J. Fararo

Against Essentialism is an original contribution. Realists about science go to war against the social constructionists to defend the traditional meaning of science. Fuchs steps into this battle zone and does a beautiful job of dissecting and defining the nature of the sociological problems involved. The result is a confident, provocative critique of various positions in the science wars. By employing system theory and dynamic network thinking, Fuchs provides a highly coherent, forceful, and persuasive account of how to think about sciences from a sociological point of view.
— Thomas J. Fararo, University of Pittsburgh

Editorial Reviews

Against Essentialism is an original contribution. Realists about science go to war against the social constructionists to defend the traditional meaning of science. Fuchs steps into this battle zone and does a beautiful job of dissecting and defining the nature of the sociological problems involved. The result is a confident, provocative critique of various positions in the science wars. By employing system theory and dynamic network thinking, Fuchs provides a highly coherent, forceful, and persuasive account of how to think about sciences from a sociological point of view.

Thomas J. Fararo

Against Essentialism presents the most diversified and extensive discussion of anti-essentialism I am aware of, bringing together a host of arguments that one usually does not find in a single volume. Fuchs lifts network theory out of its usual organizational sociological, economic sociology, and exchange theory context, and transforms it into a more constructionist and reflexive sociological theoretical framework that also manages to pay attention to microsociological dynamics. It is an original and scholarly contribution to social science theory.

Karin Knorr Cetina

Stephan Fuch's Against Essentialism is the most important work of general theory that has appeared in the last 10 years or more. It is grand theory on the level with Luhmann, Habermas, and Giddens, encompassing society, culture, knowledge, and philosophy. It is general theory both in the sense of giving a framework for all of sociology and in the sense that the word "theory" is now used in humanistic and especially literary fields, the orienting perspective on what cultural knowledge consists in. . . Among works of general theory, Fuchs stands out as remarkably well written. Against Essentialism is full of clever phrases, sharply worded titles and subtitles that point up the keys to the argument, lapidary formulations that could serve as catchwords. Fuchs is surely one of the wittiest writers in sociology and many other fields. Through rather complex arguments he retains a crisp and clear writing style, making the book eminently readable.

Sociological Theory - Randall Collins

In Against Essentialism, Stephan Fuchs offers a clever, intelligent, and robust defense of the deep structural properties of capital-S Sociology.

Sociological Theory - Charles Lembert

Fuchs...has synthesized systems theory...and network theory into a comprehensive sociology of knowledge and culture...This work will be much discussed by sociologists and is essential for any library supporting programs in social thought.

Choice - J. L. Croissant

Against Essentialism is a brilliant book. Like certain martial artists, Fuchs uses the strengths of his enemies to confound them. Against post-modernists who view the social constructedness of culture as reason to abandon the substantive goals of old-fashioned sociological positivism, Fuchs deploys an even more thoroughgoing constructivism to re-envision as sociological variables the issues in dispute between constructivists and positivists. This is a stunning achievement. I can't think of a book whose publication I would more eagerly anticipate...and as much for the controversy it will create as for its contribution to the discipline.

Mark A. Schneider

In Against Essentialism, Stephan Fuchs offers a clever, intelligent, and robust defense of the deep structural properties of capital-S Sociology.
— Charles Lembert

Sociological Theory

Fuchs...has synthesized systems theory...and network theory into a comprehensive sociology of knowledge and culture...This work will be much discussed by sociologists and is essential for any library supporting programs in social thought.
— J. L. Croissant

Choice