Norm Ornstein
"America, Compromised is about the country in the Trump era, but not about Trump. Indeed, Lessig would have written much the same book if Hillary Clinton were president and if Democrats had control of both houses of Congress. His focus is not on bad people doing bad things, but on how incentives across a range of institutions have created corruption, with deleterious consequences for the nation. . . . America, Compromised join[s] an impressive array of books and essays that may, someday, have a future intellectual historian using them as examples to lament the fact that his or her contemporaries are not as eloquent or important as the group that arose in the Trump era to combat the threats to our way of life."
Cory Doctorow
"Lessig lays out a working definition and theory of corruption that is at once simple and comprehensive, a devastating argument that America is racing for the cliff's edge of structural, possibly irreversible tyranny."
Kirkus Reviews
2018-08-13
A Harvard law professor presents the case that America has become structurally compromised with a pervasiveness that transcends individual corruption.
In a book based on a series of lectures, Lessig (Republic Lost: 2.0, 2015), co-founder of Creative Commons, focuses on how the country's institutions are no longer serving the purposes for which they were designed. They have succumbed to third-party interests: wealthy, corporate, market forces, all of which have vested interests in helping the rich get richer. "My belief is that we have allowed core institutions of America's economic, social, and political life to become corrupted," writes the author. "Not by evil souls, but by good souls. Not through crime, but through compromise." In our current situation, wealth exerts its influence wherever such influence can manifest itself, from campaign financing that restricts the choices of candidates from which average Americans can choose to academic research funded for the benefit of those doing the funding. Lessig also shows how pharmaceutical companies have compromised the profession of psychiatry, promoting the dubious concept of "chemical imbalance" that can be balanced by prescription, and how market forces and technological disruption have transformed media in general and journalism in particular, catering to the appetite for junk food where democracy demands nourishment. The author is more convincing in his case against "institutional corruption" than in finding the solution. As he writes in the chapter on the media, where he suggests that journalism might better become more transparently partisan, some readers might think his proposal "seems just nuts." Similarly, his borrowing of a proposal for "deliberative polling"—leaving discussions of issues and nominations in the hands of 1,000 or so randomly selected yet representative participants—isn't likely to be adopted any time soon. Yet the book has value in showing how much that ails America isn't illegal or even unethical but systemic.
The diagnosis rings truer than the cures.
