Animal Rights Without Liberation: Applied Ethics and Human Obligations

by Alasdair Cochrane

Overview

Alasdair Cochrane introduces an entirely new theory of animal rights grounded in their interests as sentient beings. He then applies this theory to different and underexplored policy areas, such as genetic engineering, pet-keeping, indigenous hunting, and religious slaughter. In contrast to other proponents of animal rights, Cochrane claims that because most sentient animals are not autonomous agents, they have no intrinsic interest in liberty. As such, he argues that our obligations to animals lie in ending practices that cause their suffering and death and do not require the liberation of animals.

Cochrane's "interest-based rights approach" weighs the interests of animals to determine which is sufficient to impose strict duties on humans. In so doing, Cochrane acknowledges that sentient animals have a clear and discernable right not to be made to suffer and not to be killed, but he argues that they do not have a prima facie right to liberty. Because most animals possess no interest in leading freely chosen lives, humans have no moral obligation to liberate them. Moving beyond theory to the practical aspects of applied ethics, this pragmatic volume provides much-needed perspective on the realities and responsibilities of the human-animal relationship.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780231504430
Publisher:	Columbia University Press
Publication date:	08/21/2012
Series:	Critical Perspectives on Animals: Theory, Culture, Science, and Law
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	256
Lexile:	1240L (what's this?)
File size:	2 MB

About the Author

Alasdair Cochrane is lecturer in political theory at The University of Sheffield and the author of An Introduction to Animals and Political Theory.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments
1. Introduction
2. Animals, Interests, and Rights
3. Animal Experimentation
4. Animal Agriculture
5. Animals and Genetic Engineering
6. Animal Entertainment
7. Animals and the Environment
8. Animals and Cultural Practices
9. Conclusion
Notes
Bibliography
Index

What People are Saying About This

Peter Singer

In this clearly written book, Cochrane breaks down the facile dichotomy between "animal welfare" and "animal rights." In doing so, he makes a useful contribution to the debate over the moral status of animals.

— Peter Singer, author of Animal Liberation

Editorial Reviews

Alasdair Cochrane argues that there is a plausible theory of animal rights that allows us to continue to own and use animals. It would be an understatement to say that I disagree with Cochrane but he does a fine job presenting the argument and his book will surely provoke debate and discussion.

Gary L. Francione

...thoughtful and thought-provoking, making it a welcome and highly recommended addition to personal and academic library Contemporary Ethics reference collections and supplemental reading lists.Midwest Book Review

Midwest Book Review

Well-argued

Political Science Review

This is the first sustained and comprehensive attempt to base a whole account of animal rights around an interest-based theory of rights, and the first to use such a theory to deny that animals have an intrinsic right to liberty. It dispels once and for all the myth that animal rights must be about condemning all uses of animals and that a failure to do so commits one to an acceptance of an animal welfare ethic.

Robert Garner

Non-human animals may have morally relevant interests in avoiding suffering and death without also possessing comparable interests in non-interference. By drawing on this neglected insight into the specificity of animals' interests, Cochrane's rigorous yet accessible book exposes a false dichotomy that has divided animal ethicists for decades, making a major advance in our understanding of the subject.

Paula Casal