‘an essential book … closely-reasoned, formidably intelligent and utterly compelling … required reading across the political spectrum … important and riveting’
Roy Foster, The Times
‘an outstanding new book on the IRA … a calm, rational but in the end devastating deconstruction of the IRA’
Henry McDonald, Observer
‘superb … the first full history of the IRA and the best overall account of the organization. English writes to the highest scholarly standards … Moreover, he writes with the common reader in mind: he has crafted a fine balance of detail and analysis and his prose is clear, fresh and jargon-free … sets a new standard for debate on republicanism’
Peter Hart, Irish Times
‘a work which eclipses all other studies of the IRA and must now be regarded as the single most important book on the topic … a penetrating and rewarding study’
Keith Jeffery, Times Literary Supplement
‘excellent book’ Patrick Bishop, Daily Telegraph
‘the best analytical history of the IRA yet written. Even those who grew up with the Troubles will find it a provocative and freshly compelling work. More importantly, perhaps, fifty years from now it will still be required reading – generations who look back and wonder what the Northern conflict was all about will find many of their answers here. Superb … the rigour and depth of English’s analysis is exceptional’
Niall Strange, Sunday Business Post
‘fluent, fascinating account of the origins, actions and ideologies of that caucus of shadows, the Provisional IRA … an enormous challenge of narrative, historical research and tact. In all these regards, English succeeds … his description of what he refers to as the “personal” consequences of republican violence is ultimately as heartbreaking as it is dispassionate’
Joseph O’Neill, Guardian
‘a great book. What impressed me most was the way Richard English managed to present such an historical and contradictory mess with such clarity and fairness. The book grabbed and held me like a very good novel’
Roddy Doyle, author of A Star Called Henry
‘This is a book whose time has come. At a historic moment when Irish republicanism is in the process of redefining itself, a highly-talented historian gives a compelling analysis of its past. The book’s genius lies in its non-judgemental approach, an approach which has induced many leading republicans to speak more frankly to Richard English than they have done to any previous historian. This mixture of skilful historical research and totally new personal statements from key republicans makes this a captivating, authoritative and highly readable book. It is masterly and hard-hitting and is likely to become something of a modern classic.’
Marianne Elliott, author of The Catholics of Ulster
‘an impressive achievement … Richard English’s study is the most probing and thorough analysis
Since the signing of the 1998 Good Friday Agreement, the peace process in Northern Ireland has been in almost perpetual crisis. Unionists have demanded that the IRA destroy all its weapons as a precondition to power sharing. The IRA sees giving in to such a demand as tantamount to admitting defeat. The result has been a frustrating political stalemate. English's balanced and complex account of the IRA, more particularly the Provisional IRA, will help anyone understand the strong feelings and difficult issues behind today's headlines. English (Ernie O'Malley: IRA Intellectual) emphasizes that the IRA has "courageously shifted ground" by accepting the concept of consent (i.e., that the island of Ireland won't be unified without the consent of the people of Northern Ireland), rather than continuing to pursue the violent reunification of Ireland. Indeed, English stresses, the Good Friday Agreement has split the IRA just as the 1922 treaty partitioning Ireland did. The author, a professor of politics at Queen's University in Belfast, makes some controversial assertions, as when he claims that the IRA's post-1969 violence, ostensibly aimed at protecting Catholics, only led to increased anti-Catholic carnage. Even more controversially, English calls into question the whole point of the long IRA war. What English does brilliantly is to describe the IRA's own justifications for its war against Britain, with special attention to the socialism pervading much IRA belief. He has written a provocative and essential book for anyone trying to understand Northern Ireland's tempestuous recent history, providing even better insight into the IRA's ideology than Ed Moloney's recent A Secret History of the IRA. Illus., maps not seen by PW. (Aug.) Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.
English (politics, Queen's Univ., Belfast; History of Ireland) clarifies early on that the IRA of which he writes is the Provisional IRA ("the Provos"), and though he looks at the civil war, he focuses on "the Troubles." Drawing on books, newspapers, TV broadcasts, and interviews, he reviews the IRA's activities and pronouncements over the decades, looking for its core beliefs. Philosophically, the IRA has drifted over time, as has its popular support. What drifts in this history is objectivity. Perhaps the IRA has aggravated, not shortened, the struggle for peace. Perhaps Ulster's Protestants have nonpolitical reasons for not wanting to join the Republic. And perhaps the IRA's strategy of causing the U.K. more pain than Ulster is worth has proved faulty. But you won't learn that here. Whether he intended to or not, English seems to justify the IRA's violence. In page after page, he chronicles the IRA' s bombings, killings, kidnappings, and attacks as tragic but necessary within the political context and Protestant response as just vengeful. Ultimately, what is most frustrating is that English doesn't explain precisely how peace has come to pass. He concedes that it was not brought about by the IRA's violence but insists that the Provos weren't the worst villains in the Troubles. Perhaps. This is not the history of the IRA but only the latest history-and a tendentious one at that. For larger collections.-Robert Moore, Bristol-Myers Squibb Medical Imaging, Billerica, MA Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.
"This an essential book. At a stroke it replaces the many journalistic 'histories' of the IRA, too often flaccid and shoddy."—Roy Foster, The Times (London)
"A fluent, fascinating account of the origins, actions and ideologies of that caucus of shadows, the Provisional IRA."—Observer"This vivid, reflective work will likely become the standard introduction to the subject. It also serves as a valuable corrective for anyone who thinks that the difficulties in Northern Ireland are amenable to quick-fix solutions."—Financial Times"With fine detail and a flair for narrative, Richard English chronicles the rise of the IRA from the ashes of the Easter rising to the promise of peace today. Balanced and thoughtful, Armed Struggle offers new insight into Ireland's republican movement. And it reminds us, in the author's words, that 'the voices of the victims still deafen.'"—Terry Golway, author of The Irish in America"About Richard English's Armed Struggle: History of the IRA there is a kind of passionate objectivity you'll rarely find on this subject. The author works mightily to present two sides of a story that keeps shifting. You might read the book wondering, perhaps, where his sympathies lie, but even if you sneak a look at the last chapter, where he lays out his credentials, you'll come away impressed with his balance and fairness. I am neither scholar nor historian, but this is the one book I recommend for anyone trying to understand the craziness and complexity of the Northern Ireland tragedy."—Frank McCourt, author of Angela's Ashes"What impressed me most was the way Richard English managed to present such an historical and contradictory mess with such clarity and fairness. The book grabbed and held me like a very good novel."—Roddy Doyle, author of A Star Called Henry"Here is the book we have been waiting for—the first full history of the I.R.A. and the best account by far of the twentieth century's longest war. Richard English has read everything—from secret documents to the Long Kesh library —and he has talked to the men who fought the war. He also brings a rare balance of empathy and judgement to a topic that desperately needs both. The result is a superb piece of writing: clear, insightful, and engrossing. If you want to know where the I.R.A. came from and how they think, this is the book to read."—Peter Hart, Chair of Irish Studies, Memorial University and the author of The IRA and It's Enemies"English's balanced and complex account of the IRA, more particularly the Provisional IRA, will help anyone understand the strong feelings and difficult issues behind today's headlines.... The author, a professor of politics at Queen's University in Belfast, makes some controversial assertions, as when he claims that the IRA's post-1969 violence, ostensibly aimed at protecting Catholics, only lead to increased anti-Catholic carnage. Even more controversially, English calls into question the whole point of the long IRA war. What English does brilliantly is to describe the IRA's own justifications for its war against Britain, with special attention to the socialism pervading much of IRA belief. He has written a provocative and essential book for anyone trying to understand Northern Ireland's tempestuous recent history."—Publishers Weekly
