The New York Times Book Review
Turner is a good writer in possession of a great story. Brigham Young is a landmark work, written by a Gentile, as the Saints call non-Mormons, with the active cooperation of the church. If Young could make the Saints dance, I wished at times that Turner would make this double-barreled, all-American story sing. That said, Turner more than compensates for his stylistic formality with exhaustive research, excellent judgment and an abiding sense of fairness…Turner is on the side of good history, and he generally negotiates the many tripwires in the Saints' story…with aplomb.
—Alex Beam
Richard Bushman
The story Turner tells in this elegantly written biography will startle and shock many readers. He reveals a Brigham Young more violent and coarse than the man Mormons have known. While lauding his achievements as pioneer, politician, and church leader, the book will require a reassessment of Brigham Young the man.
Alex Beam
Brigham Young is a landmark work… There is no aspect of Young’s fascinating life that eludes Turner’s scrutiny.
Standpoint - Jeremy Black
Fascinating… Young very much emerges with his faults manifest in Turner’s impressive biography. At the same time, [Brigham Young] takes Mormon studies forward, avoiding the pitfalls of apologia and polemic.
Richard Aldous
Young’s life is admirably chronicled in this fine new biography… The character who emerges from Turner’s elegantly written and well-researched biography is a man for whom the word ‘protean’ might almost have been invented. He became one of the foremost colonizers of American history, leading the Mormons on a perilous journey to the Great Basin and laying claim to approximately a sixth of the western United States… Turner shows [Young] to be a shrewd and subtle politician… Turner’s story never drags, partly because the tale itself is so fascinating, but also because he writes with clarity and energy.
William Deverell
Inextricably tied together by bonds of fate and faith, Brigham Young and Mormonism rose as one in nineteenth-century America. It is that America, as well as that man and that religion, that Turner explores and explains so well in this wonderful book.
Salt Lake Tribune - Gary James Bergera
A major accomplishment that, more than any past treatment of Young, situates the protean prophet squarely in the context of his turbulent times. Turner is not a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and brings to Young an emotional objectivity and distance that greatly benefit his profile of the 19th century Mormon leader and colonizer… Turner unflinchingly tackles the full spectrum, warts and all, of Young’s multifarious personality and life… For Turner, no topic is off-limits, too controversial, too intimate. He exhibits a healthy skepticism and curiosity that are as bracing as they are salutary… He is balanced, insightful, sympathetic, even occasionally affectionate. Turner’s Young is a far cry from the (take your pick) superficial, cartoonish, angelic/devilish caricatures of most popularized portrayals. He is a fully rendered, flesh-and-blood, flawed-but-earnest human being who sincerely believed he had been ‘called’ to govern God’s new covenant people as heaven’s representative. The biography adds much to both our understanding and appreciation of Young.
Ken Verdoia
Turner provides a searing portrait of a leader at his most determined and—at times—ruthless in defense of his religion. A provocative and compelling view of one of the most elusive, yet influential, figures in our nation’s westward expansion.
Books & Culture - Stephen H. Webb
[A] magnificent new biography… [Turner’s] book should establish him as one of the best religious historians of his generation. Turner had unfettered access to Young’s papers, and his keen eye for social context makes this book an excellent introduction to the story of Mormonism as well as an essential addition to the history of the American West. It should also do for Brigham Young what Richard Lyman Bushman’s Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling did for the Mormon prophet: make the case not only that Young was one of the most fascinating people of the 19th century but also that his importance in American history can no longer be overlooked. Indeed, some of that history will have to be revised to fit this ‘pioneer prophet’ into its narrative… Turner’s prose is so smooth and his interpretations so balanced that I suspect Mormonism’s defenders and detractors alike will flock to this book… Turner is not a member of the Mormon church, which makes his achievement all the more remarkable.
Philip L. Barlow
Turner’s treatment of the complex Brigham Young is unsentimental, cogent, critical, and fair. It takes its place alongside Leonard Arrington’s magisterial American Moses as the essential, mutually challenging portraits of one of America’s greatest colonizers and religious figures.
Choice - D. Liestman
[Turner] presents a very thoughtful, well-contextualized account of a complex and contradictory religious leader who was profane as well as pious and powerful. The book traces the development of an aimless young man who became the prophet and president of a sprawling theocracy. Turner offers a fair consideration of Young… This well-researched, readable biography will satisfy all but the most partisan reader.
National Review - Jason Lee Steorts
Turner offers an unflinching account of Young’s life ‘within the context of mid-19th-century American religion and politics,’ yet evinces throughout a sympathetic understanding of the way Young and the Mormon pioneers saw themselves: as a chosen people delivered by God from their persecutors and led to a latter-day Zion… Turner’s portrait is of a man both great and greatly flawed.
Booklist (starred review) - Bryce Christensen
Turner’s broad historical perspective clarifies why Young’s ecclesiastical successors have still felt the man’s influence—even after abandoning polygamy. An impressively detailed portrait of a controversial giant.
Cleveland Plain Dealer - Alan Cate
[Turner] provides an admirably balanced account of this complex man, and his little-understood and frequently reviled faith… When finished with this superb biography, readers will find [Brigham Young] less of a curiosity but still fascinating.
Los Angeles Review of Books - Mike Davis
John G. Turner’s new biography of Brigham Young…portrays a social experiment, the most ambitious in American history, that until Young’s death in 1877 explicitly rejected the core values of Victorian capitalism: possessive individualism and Darwinian competition.
Christian Century - Edward J. Blum
A comprehensive biography of Young and his times… It is an exceptional work… We can learn a lot about the development of Mormon theology from Turner’s book, far more than can be gleaned from previous biographies of Young… Turner is at his best when he is placing the elements of Young’s life within the main contours of broader 19th-century America… Those who want to know more about Mormonism’s birth and growth will want to get a copy.
New Yorker - Adam Gopnik
A definitive biography of Mormonism’s greatest activist and apostle.
New Republic - Jackson Lears
[A] strong and authoritative biography.
Daniel Walker Howe
In this superb new biography, Turner’s strong narrative, human insight, knowledge of context, meticulous use of sources, and sophisticated appreciation of Mormon theology combine to create an account of his larger-than-life subject that is at once informative, judicious, and profoundly engaging.
Boston Globe
In his richly researched new biography of Brigham Young, John G. Turner not only profiles the man who brought the church to Utah, but also satisfies both high-minded and lowbrow curiosity about this most American of religions.
The Nation - Chris Lehmann
The great virtue of John G. Turner’s new biography of Brigham Young—the first major study since LDS historian Leonard Arrington’s Brigham Young: American Moses (1985)—is the author’s stolid resistance to either version of the traditional Young caricature.
The Scotsman - Stuart Kelly
[An] exceptionally well-researched and endlessly interesting biography.
From the Publisher
Brigham Young is a landmark work... There is no aspect of Young's fascinating life that eludes Turner's scrutiny.--Alex Beam "New York Times Book Review" (10/21/2012 12:00:00 AM)
[An] exceptionally well-researched and endlessly interesting biography.--Stuart Kelly "The Scotsman" (9/29/2012 12:00:00 AM)
[A] magnificent new biography... [Turner's] book should establish him as one of the best religious historians of his generation. Turner had unfettered access to Young's papers, and his keen eye for social context makes this book an excellent introduction to the story of Mormonism as well as an essential addition to the history of the American West. It should also do for Brigham Young what Richard Lyman Bushman's Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling did for the Mormon prophet: make the case not only that Young was one of the most fascinating people of the 19th century but also that his importance in American history can no longer be overlooked. Indeed, some of that history will have to be revised to fit this 'pioneer prophet' into its narrative... Turner's prose is so smooth and his interpretations so balanced that I suspect Mormonism's defenders and detractors alike will flock to this book... Turner is not a member of the Mormon church, which makes his achievement all the more remarkable.--Stephen H. Webb "Books & Culture" (9/1/2012 12:00:00 AM)
[A] strong and authoritative biography.--Jackson Lears "New Republic" (10/19/2012 12:00:00 AM)
[Turner] presents a very thoughtful, well-contextualized account of a complex and contradictory religious leader who was profane as well as pious and powerful. The book traces the development of an aimless young man who became the prophet and president of a sprawling theocracy. Turner offers a fair consideration of Young... This well-researched, readable biography will satisfy all but the most partisan reader.--D. Liestman "Choice" (2/1/2013 12:00:00 AM)
[Turner] provides an admirably balanced account of this complex man, and his little-understood and frequently reviled faith... When finished with this superb biography, readers will find [Brigham Young] less of a curiosity but still fascinating.--Alan Cate "Cleveland Plain Dealer" (8/25/2012 12:00:00 AM)
A comprehensive biography of Young and his times... It is an exceptional work... We can learn a lot about the development of Mormon theology from Turner's book, far more than can be gleaned from previous biographies of Young... Turner is at his best when he is placing the elements of Young's life within the main contours of broader 19th-century America... Those who want to know more about Mormonism's birth and growth will want to get a copy.--Edward J. Blum "Christian Century" (10/17/2012 12:00:00 AM)
A definitive biography of Mormonism's greatest activist and apostle.--Adam Gopnik "New Yorker" (8/13/2012 12:00:00 AM)
A major accomplishment that, more than any past treatment of Young, situates the protean prophet squarely in the context of his turbulent times. Turner is not a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and brings to Young an emotional objectivity and distance that greatly benefit his profile of the 19th century Mormon leader and colonizer... Turner unflinchingly tackles the full spectrum, warts and all, of Young's multifarious personality and life... For Turner, no topic is off-limits, too controversial, too intimate. He exhibits a healthy skepticism and curiosity that are as bracing as they are salutary... He is balanced, insightful, sympathetic, even occasionally affectionate. Turner's Young is a far cry from the (take your pick) superficial, cartoonish, angelic/devilish caricatures of most popularized portrayals. He is a fully rendered, flesh-and-blood, flawed-but-earnest human being who sincerely believed he had been 'called' to govern God's new covenant people as heaven's representative. The biography adds much to both our understanding and appreciation of Young.--Gary James Bergera "Salt Lake Tribune" (10/6/2012 12:00:00 AM)
A scholarly yet thoroughly readable historical/biographical study, of considerable interest to students of 19th-century American history and religious revivalism.-- "Kirkus Reviews" (5/1/2012 12:00:00 AM)
Fascinating... Young very much emerges with his faults manifest in Turner's impressive biography. At the same time, [Brigham Young] takes Mormon studies forward, avoiding the pitfalls of apologia and polemic.--Jeremy Black "Standpoint" (10/26/2012 12:00:00 AM)
In his richly researched new biography of Brigham Young, John G. Turner not only profiles the man who brought the church to Utah, but also satisfies both high-minded and lowbrow curiosity about this most American of religions.-- "Boston Globe" (9/23/2012 12:00:00 AM)
John G. Turner's new biography of Brigham Young...portrays a social experiment, the most ambitious in American history, that until Young's death in 1877 explicitly rejected the core values of Victorian capitalism: possessive individualism and Darwinian competition.--Mike Davis "Los Angeles Review of Books" (10/25/2012 12:00:00 AM)
Previous biographers of Brigham Young have used epithets such as 'American Moses' and 'Lion of the Lord.' However, what Turner demonstrates here is that the three-dimensional Young cannot be reduced to saint or tyrant; he was bold, brave, crude, petty, visionary, manipulative, creative, charismatic, kindly, and much more besides. He presents Young as a family man navigating the complexities of polygamy, as a leader moving large numbers of people across the Great Plains, and as a politician negotiating enough independence for the Mormons from the American government that he could build the kingdom of God as he saw fit. Turner was given unprecedented access to the LDS church archives and he makes full use of them and other sources, as well as providing a cogent interpretive context. It is easy to forget Young's significance in American history, but at a minimum it needs to be remembered that he is responsible for settling a vast swath of the West. Turner gives him his due... There aren't enough superlatives for this book. It will remain the standard biography for a long time. Because of its thorough documentation, academics will take it seriously, while general readers will appreciate its clarity of prose and argument.--D. S. Azzolina "Library Journal (starred review)" (8/1/2012 12:00:00 AM)
The great virtue of John G. Turner's new biography of Brigham Young--the first major study since LDS historian Leonard Arrington's Brigham Young: American Moses (1985)--is the author's stolid resistance to either version of the traditional Young caricature.--Chris Lehmann "The Nation" (12/17/2012 12:00:00 AM)
Turner offers an unflinching account of Young's life 'within the context of mid-19th-century American religion and politics, ' yet evinces throughout a sympathetic understanding of the way Young and the Mormon pioneers saw themselves: as a chosen people delivered by God from their persecutors and led to a latter-day Zion... Turner's portrait is of a man both great and greatly flawed.--Jason Lee Steorts "National Review" (10/29/2012 12:00:00 AM)
Turner's broad historical perspective clarifies why Young's ecclesiastical successors have still felt the man's influence--even after abandoning polygamy. An impressively detailed portrait of a controversial giant.--Bryce Christensen "Booklist (starred review)" (8/1/2012 12:00:00 AM)
Young's life is admirably chronicled in this fine new biography... The character who emerges from Turner's elegantly written and well-researched biography is a man for whom the word 'protean' might almost have been invented. He became one of the foremost colonizers of American history, leading the Mormons on a perilous journey to the Great Basin and laying claim to approximately a sixth of the western United States... Turner shows [Young] to be a shrewd and subtle politician... Turner's story never drags, partly because the tale itself is so fascinating, but also because he writes with clarity and energy.--Richard Aldous "Irish Times" (9/22/2012 12:00:00 AM)
In this superb new biography, Turner's strong narrative, human insight, knowledge of context, meticulous use of sources, and sophisticated appreciation of Mormon theology combine to create an account of his larger-than-life subject that is at once informative, judicious, and profoundly engaging.--Daniel Walker Howe, author of What Hath God Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815-1848
The story Turner tells in this elegantly written biography will startle and shock many readers. He reveals a Brigham Young more violent and coarse than the man Mormons have known. While lauding his achievements as pioneer, politician, and church leader, the book will require a reassessment of Brigham Young the man.--Richard Bushman, author of Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling
Turner provides a searing portrait of a leader at his most determined and--at times--ruthless in defense of his religion. A provocative and compelling view of one of the most elusive, yet influential, figures in our nation's westward expansion.--Ken Verdoia, author of Utah: The Struggle for Statehood
Turner's treatment of the complex Brigham Young is unsentimental, cogent, critical, and fair. It takes its place alongside Leonard Arrington's magisterial American Moses as the essential, mutually challenging portraits of one of America's greatest colonizers and religious figures.--Philip L. Barlow, author of Mormons and the Bible: The Place of the Latter-day Saints in American Religion
Inextricably tied together by bonds of fate and faith, Brigham Young and Mormonism rose as one in nineteenth-century America. It is that America, as well as that man and that religion, that Turner explores and explains so well in this wonderful book.--William Deverell, Director, Huntington-USC Institute on California and the West
The Scotsman
[An] exceptionally well-researched and endlessly interesting biography.
— Stuart Kelly
Christian Century
A comprehensive biography of Young and his times...It is an exceptional work...We can learn a lot about the development of Mormon theology from Turner's book, far more than can be gleaned from previous biographies of Young...Turner is at his best when he is placing the elements of Young's life within the main contours of broader 19th-century America...Those who want to know more about Mormonism's birth and growth will want to get a copy.
— Edward J. Blum
National Review
Turner offers an unflinching account of Young's life "within the context of mid-19th-century American religion and politics," yet evinces throughout a sympathetic understanding of the way Young and the Mormon pioneers saw themselves: as a chosen people delivered by God from their persecutors and led to a latter-day Zion...Turner's portrait is of a man both great and greatly flawed.
— Jason Lee Steorts
Salt Lake Tribune
A major accomplishment that, more than any past treatment of Young, situates the protean prophet squarely in the context of his turbulent times. Turner is not a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and brings to Young an emotional objectivity and distance that greatly benefit his profile of the 19th century Mormon leader and colonizer...Turner unflinchingly tackles the full spectrum, warts and all, of Young's multifarious personality and life...For Turner, no topic is off-limits, too controversial, too intimate. He exhibits a healthy skepticism and curiosity that are as bracing as they are salutary...He is balanced, insightful, sympathetic, even occasionally affectionate. Turner's Young is a far cry from the (take your pick) superficial, cartoonish, angelic/devilish caricatures of most popularized portrayals. He is a fully rendered, flesh-and-blood, flawed-but-earnest human being who sincerely believed he had been "called" to govern God's new covenant people as heaven's representative. The biography adds much to both our understanding and appreciation of Young.
— Gary James Bergera
New York Times Book Review
Brigham Young is a landmark work...There is no aspect of Young's fascinating life that eludes Turner's scrutiny.
— Alex Beam
Irish Times
Young's life is admirably chronicled in this fine new biography…The character who emerges from Turner's elegantly written and well-researched biography is a man for whom the word 'protean' might almost have been invented. He became one of the foremost colonizers of American history, leading the Mormons on a perilous journey to the Great Basin and laying claim to approximately a sixth of the western United States…Turner shows [Young] to be a shrewd and subtle politician…Turner's story never drags, partly because the tale itself is so fascinating, but also because he writes with clarity and energy.
— Richard Aldous
Cleveland Plain Dealer
[Turner] provides an admirably balanced account of this complex man, and his little-understood and frequently reviled faith...When finished with this superb biography, readers will find [Brigham Young] less of a curiosity but still fascinating.
— Alan Cate
Books & Culture
[A] magnificent new biography...[Turner's] book should establish him as one of the best religious historians of his generation. Turner had unfettered access to Young's papers, and his keen eye for social context makes this book an excellent introduction to the story of Mormonism as well as an essential addition to the history of the American West. It should also do for Brigham Young what Richard Lyman Bushman's Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling did for the Mormon prophet: make the case not only that Young was one of the most fascinating people of the 19th century but also that his importance in American history can no longer be overlooked. Indeed, some of that history will have to be revised to fit this "pioneer prophet" into its narrative...Turner's prose is so smooth and his interpretations so balanced that I suspect Mormonism's defenders and detractors alike will flock to this book...Turner is not a member of the Mormon church, which makes his achievement all the more remarkable.
— Stephen H. Webb
New Yorker
A definitive biography of Mormonism's greatest activist and apostle.
— Adam Gopnik
Booklist (starred review)
Turner's broad historical perspective clarifies why Young's ecclesiastical successors have still felt the man's influence—even after abandoning polygamy. An impressively detailed portrait of a controversial giant.
— Bryce Christensen
Library Journal
Previous biographers of Brigham Young have used epithets such as "American Moses" and "Lion of the Lord." However, what Turner (religious studies, George Mason Univ.; Bill Bright and Campus Crusade for Christ) demonstrates here is that Young cannot be reduced to saint or tyrant; he was bold, brave, crude, petty, visionary, manipulative, creative, charismatic, kindly, and much more besides. Turner presents Young as a family man navigating the complexities of polygamy, as a leader moving large numbers of people across the Great Plains, and as a politician negotiating enough independence for the Mormons from the U.S. government that he could build the kingdom of God as he saw fit. Turner was given unprecedented access to the LDS church archives and he makes full use of them and other sources, as well as providing a cogent interpretive context. It is easy to forget Young's significance in American history, but at a minimum it needs to be remembered that he is responsible for settling a vast swath of the West. VERDICT There aren't enough superlatives for this book. It will remain the standard biography for a long time. Because of its thorough documentation, academics will take it seriously, while general readers will appreciate its clarity of prose and argument.—David Azzolina, Univ. of Pennsylvania Lib., Philadelphia
Kirkus Reviews
Sprawling life of a larger-than-life character in the history of the American West. Brigham Young was Joseph Smith's lieutenant in spreading the newly coined doctrine of Mormonism and his successor on Smith's murder. Young carved a homeland out of the Utah wilderness, which was heavily settled by inconvenient Lamanites, as the Mormons called Native peoples. As Turner (History/Univ. of South Alabama; Bill Bright and Campus Crusade for Christ: The Renewal of Evangelicalism in Postwar America, 2008) capably demonstrates, Young's successes were the fruit of a driving ambition that sometimes manifested itself in ruthlessness. Turner writes carefully--a good tactic, for Mormon history is an always-fraught topic--of Young's rise in the early hierarchy, including an episode in which he "confronted Smith and his two counselors in the church's presidency…about their lingering grievances," divisions that might have yielded a schism had not Young also been a skilled strategist. Dissent was a constant companion in Young's life, and Turner, to his credit, does not shy from noting that fact. Moreover, the author looks at the various strains of Protestantism, "ecstatic" and otherwise, that fed into early Mormonism, drawing particularly on Methodism in the British Isles, where Young worked as one of the church's first missionaries. Some of the resulting ideas, blended with Smith's own, were unusual in the religious landscape of the time. Of interest--and potential controversy--is Turner's attention to Young's many wives, who were not always happy with the arrangement and some of whom cut their ties with him; it's not exactly Big Love, but there's some high drama in the text. Drama also prevails in the passages related to the infamous Mountain Meadows Massacre and the subsequent execution of Young lieutenant John D. Lee, who insisted that "Young and other church leaders had selected him as their ‘scapegoat.' " A scholarly yet thoroughly readable historical/biographical study, of considerable interest to students of 19th-century American history and religious revivalism.
