The book is well researched, clear, and of interest to political theorists, philosophers, and readers interested in contemporary struggles for intranational political recognition.
Ethics: An International Journal of Social
An examination and critique of the theoretical and political efforts of Taylor to promote "deep diversity" as an antidote to the process of political fragmentation in general and, specifically, in his home of Quebec. Redhead (political theory, Oregon State U.) argues that Taylor's opposition to Quebecois separatists is equally rooted in a political theory of communitarian liberalism, his political activities within the New Democratic Party of Canada and Quebec, his understanding of his Catholic faith, and his experiences growing up in an Anglo-French household. Redhead argues that Taylor's philosophy ultimately fails to address questions of nationalist projects that "simplify identity" or questions of openness to different moral ontologies. Annotation c. Book News, Inc., Portland, OR (booknews.com)
The book is well researched, clear, and of interest to political theorists, philosophers, and readers interested in contemporary struggles for intranational political recognition.
Ethics: An International Journal of Social
Mark Readhead's book is one of the closest studies to date of Charles Taylor's life and thought. Charles Taylor displays the sort of careful, meditative, generous temperament for which Taylor is widely admired, suggesting that Redhead is in an excellent position to respond to the above challenges and to continue to help us think beyond his subject.
Cultural diversity today is not an academic issue, but a lived reality for many societies in the grip of globalization. No contemporary thinker has reflected more seriously on this reality than Charles Taylor whose work champions a recognition of 'deep diversity' as an alternative to communal homogeneity and atomistic fragmentation. Redhead examines this perspective on numerous levels—political, philosophical, and personal—thus offering a perceptive entree into the Canadian's complex opus, while also suggesting a more pragmatic solution to some remaining quandaries in that work.
Mark Redhead places the theme of 'deep diversity' at the center of his study of Charles Taylor; he attempts to elucidate Taylor via a 'deep analysis,' treating Taylor not only as a thinker, with roots, e.g., in Hegel, but taking very seriously Taylor's involvement in Canadian politics, his Catholic faith, as well as his personal experience growing up in an Anglo-French Quebec household. Redhead manages not only to shed much new light on Taylor, but his book serves as a model for the study of a serious thinker in terms of the interaction of life and thought. Without ever being reductionist Redhead gives us a very rich picture of Taylor—and some astute reflections on the limitations of Taylor as a political philosopher. Redhead's study of Taylor and 'deep diversity' must be judged 'deeply successful.'
Readhead's book is worth reading, especially for its descriptive portrayal of Taylor's thought.
Cultural diversity today is not an academic issue, but a lived reality for many societies in the grip of globalization. No contemporary thinker has reflected more seriously on this reality than Charles Taylor whose work champions a recognition of 'deep diversity' as an alternative to communal homogeneity and atomistic fragmentation. Redhead examines this perspective on numerous levels—political, philosophical, and personal—thus offering a perceptive entree into the Canadian's complex opus, while also suggesting a more pragmatic solution to some remaining quandaries in that work.
Cultural diversity today is not an academic issue, but a lived reality for many societies in the grip of globalization. No contemporary thinker has reflected more seriously on this reality than Charles Taylor whose work champions a recognition of 'deep diversity' as an alternative to communal homogeneity and atomistic fragmentation. Redhead examines this perspective on numerous levels--political, philosophical, and personal--thus offering a perceptive entree into the Canadian's complex opus, while also suggesting a more pragmatic solution to some remaining quandaries in that work.--Fred R. Dallmayr, Packey J. Dee Professor Emeritus, University of Notre Dame
