Contested Rituals: Circumcision, Kosher Butchering, and Jewish Political Life in Germany, 1843-1933

by Robin Judd

Overview

In Contested Rituals, Robin Judd shows that circumcision and kosher butchering became focal points of political struggle among the German state, its municipal governments, Jews, and Gentiles. In 1843, some German-Jewish fathers refused to circumcise their sons, prompting their Jewish communities to reconsider their standards for membership. Nearly a century later, in 1933, another blood ritual, kosher butchering, served as a political and cultural touchstone when the Nazis built upon a decades-old controversy concerning the practice and prohibited it.

In describing these events and related controversies that raged during the intervening years, Judd explores the nature and escalation of the ritual debates as they transcended the boundaries of the local Jewish community to include non-Jews who sought to protect, restrict, or prohibit these rites. Judd argues that the ritual debates grew out of broad shifts in German politics: the competition between local and regional authority following unification, the possibility of government intervention in private affairs, the place of religious difference in the modern age, and the relationship of the German state to its religious and ethnic minorities, including Catholics. Anti-Semitism was only one factor driving the debates and it often functioned in unexpected ways. Judd gives us a new understanding of the formation of German political systems, the importance of religious practices to Jewish political leadership, the interaction of Jews with the German government, and the reaction of Germans of all faiths to political change.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780801445453
Publisher:	Cornell University Press
Publication date:	08/15/2007
Edition description:	New Edition
Pages:	304
Product dimensions:	6.12(w) x 9.25(h) x 0.94(d)
Age Range:	18 Years

About the Author

Robin Judd is Assistant Professor of History at The Ohio State University.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments     ix
Introduction: Rituals, Identities, and Politics     1
The Circumcision Questions in the German-Speaking Lands, 1843-1857     21
German Unification, Emancipation, and the "Ritual Questions"     58
The Radicalization of the Ritual Questions, 1880-1916     86
"The Disgrace of Our Century!" Circumcision, Kosher Butchering, and Modern German Politics     122
The Schachtfragen and Jewish Political Behavior     154
A "Renaissance" for the Ritual Questions? The Ritual Debates of the Weimar Republic     190
Epilogue     239
Bibliography     249
Index     275

What People are Saying About This

Paula E. Hyman

Exploring two issues that brought Jews and the practice of Judaism into the German public arena from the 1840s through the Weimar era, Robin Judd brilliantly illuminates German politics, the identities of German Jews, Jewish self-defense strategies, and antisemitism. In her nuanced and well-written book, she has demonstrated that a focus on antisemitism alone does justice neither to German debates about Jewish issues nor to the status of Jews in Germany.

David N. Myers

It seems as if no public discussion of Jewish circumcision or kosher slaughtering in Germany in the nineteenth or twentieth centuries has escaped Robin Judd's attention. She brings these sources together in a coherent and well-written account of a provocative, and at times bloody topic. Beyond the intricacies and intrigue of individual cases, negotiations about ritual slaughter and circumcision amounted to an assertive new politics for German Jews. Contested Rituals demonstrates the unusual alliances forged both within and beyond the Jewish community.

Helmut Walser Smith

Contested Rituals is a crucially important book that gives us for the first time a story of Jewish assimilation and integration in Germany told as a story about Jewish ritual. Robin Judd recreates the discourse around circumcision and ritual slaughter, and the politics of their acceptance and rejection, to explain the formation of the Jewish community in the context of emancipation, shifting politics, war, democracy, and the rise of National Socialism. Judd shows that the question of Jewish ritual was caught up in the maelstrom of German culture and politics more generally. Contested Rituals is a fine example of the complicated, truthful new German Jewish history.

Editorial Reviews

"It seems as if no public discussion of Jewish circumcision or kosher slaughtering in Germany in the nineteenth or twentieth centuries has escaped Robin Judd's attention. She brings these sources together in a coherent and well-written account of a provocative, and at times bloody topic. Beyond the intricacies and intrigue of individual cases, negotiations about ritual slaughter and circumcision amounted to an assertive new politics for German Jews. Contested Rituals demonstrates the unusual alliances forged both within and beyond the Jewish community."

David N. Myers

"Exploring two issues that brought Jews and the practice of Judaism into the German public arena from the 1840s through the Weimar era, Robin Judd brilliantly illuminates German politics, the identities of German Jews, Jewish self-defense strategies, and antisemitism. In her nuanced and well-written book, she has demonstrated that a focus on antisemitism alone does justice neither to German debates about Jewish issues nor to the status of Jews in Germany."

Paula E. Hyman

"Contested Rituals is a crucially important book that gives us for the first time a story of Jewish assimilation and integration in Germany told as a story about Jewish ritual. Robin Judd recreates the discourse around circumcision and ritual slaughter, and the politics of their acceptance and rejection, to explain the formation of the Jewish community in the context of emancipation, shifting politics, war, democracy, and the rise of National Socialism. Judd shows that the question of Jewish ritual was caught up in the maelstrom of German culture and politics more generally. Contested Rituals is a fine example of the complicated, truthful new German Jewish history."

Helmut Walser Smith

"Exploring two issues that brought Jews and the practice of Judaism into the German public arena from the 1840s through the Weimar era, Robin Judd brilliantly illuminates German politics, the identities of German Jews, Jewish self-defense strategies, and antisemitism. In her nuanced and well-written book, she has demonstrated that a focus on antisemitism alone does justice neither to German debates about Jewish issues nor to the status of Jews in Germany."—Paula E. Hyman, Lucy Moses Professor of Modern Jewish History, Yale University

"It seems as if no public discussion of Jewish circumcision or kosher slaughtering in Germany in the nineteenth or twentieth centuries has escaped Robin Judd's attention. She brings these sources together in a coherent and well-written account of a provocative, and at times bloody topic. Beyond the intricacies and intrigue of individual cases, negotiations about ritual slaughter and circumcision amounted to an assertive new politics for German Jews. Contested Rituals demonstrates the unusual alliances forged both within and beyond the Jewish community."—David N. Myers, Professor of History and Director of the UCLA Center for Jewish Studies, UCLA

"Contested Rituals is a crucially important book that gives us for the first time a story of Jewish assimilation and integration in Germany told as a story about Jewish ritual. Robin Judd recreates the discourse around circumcision and ritual slaughter, and the politics of their acceptance and rejection, to explain the formation of the Jewish community in the context of emancipation, shifting politics, war, democracy, and the rise of National Socialism. Judd shows that the question of Jewish ritual was caught up in the maelstrom of German culture and politics more generally. Contested Rituals is a fine example of the complicated, truthful new German Jewish history."—Helmut Walser Smith, Martha Rivers Ingram Professor of History and Director of the Robert Penn Warren Center for the Humanities, Vanderbilt University

From the Publisher