Critical International Political Economy: Dialogue, Debate and Dissensus

by Stuart Shields, Ian Bruff, Huw Macartney

Overview

Amidst the continued debate surrounding the foundations of IPE, coupled with recent methodological and theoretical divides this book argues that an attempt should be made to re-visit the notion of the 'critical'. The challenge posed by contributors to this volume is to assess the development of so-called critical IPE and interrogate whether the theoretical foundations it was built upon have reached their potential. The essays in this volume take up this challenge in a number of different ways but all share a common concern - to re-assess the purpose of critical approaches, reflect on why certain social theorists have been favoured as a point of departure, yet others have largely been ignored. In light of recent debates on the notion of a 'trans-Atlantic divide' within IPE the collection the contributors aim demonstrates how the distinction between the 'critical' and the 'orthodox' (or 'empirical') is only significant if the 'critical' is geared towards a larger, more substantial body of critical social enquiry and engages with what it means to conduct such enquiry.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781137585523
Publisher:	Palgrave Macmillan UK
Publication date:	02/01/2011
Series:	International Political Economy Series
Edition description:	1st ed. 2011
Pages:	195
Product dimensions:	5.51(w) x 8.50(h) x (d)

About the Author

Stuart Shields is Senior Lecturer in International Political Economy at the University of Manchester, UK. His book The International Political Economy of Transition (2012) was shortlisted for the 2013 BISA IPEG book prize.

Ian Bruff is Lecturer in European Politics at the University of Manchester, UK. He has published widely on European political economy(ies), debates on comparing capitalisms, neoliberalism, and social theory, and is currently researching the political economy of neoliberalism in Europe.

Huw Macartney is Lecturer in Political Economy at the University of Birmingham, UK. He is the author of European Democratic Legitimacy and the Debt Crisis (2013) and Variegated Neoliberalism: European Varieties of Capitalism and International Political Economy (2010).

Table of Contents

Introduction: 'Critical' and 'International Political Economy'; S.Shields, I.Bruff & H.Macartney

PART I: DIALOGUE

Missing Voices: Critical IPE, Disciplinary History and H.N. Brailsford's Analysis of the Capitalist International Anarchy; L.M.Ashworth

Space, the latest frontier? A scalar-relational approach to critical IPE; H.Macartney & S.Shields

Poststructuralism in/and IPE; P.Griffin

PART II: DEBATE

New Marxism and the Problem of Subjectivity: Towards a Critical and Historical International Political Economy; R.Germain

Overcoming the State/Market Dichotomy; I.Bruff

Critical Feminist Scholarship and IPE; J.Elias

PART III: DISSENSUS

Reclaiming Critical IPE from the 'British' School; O.Worth

'What's Critical about Critical Theory?' Feminist Materialism, Intersectionality and the Social Totality of the Frankfurt School; A.Fischer & D.Tepe

Knowledge versus Power in the Field of IPE; P.Cammack

Conclusion: IPE and the International Political Economy? IPE or the International Political Economy?; S.Shields, I.Bruff & H.Macartney

What People are Saying About This

From the Publisher

"Cause for celebration: a 'critical' volume on IPE that is worthy of the name. This innovative text is not only a good read but a crucial contribution at a critical moment. It breaks out of stale boxes and sterile debates, asks silenced questions, takes us in new directions, and gets real about being critical." – V. Spike Peterson, University of Arizona, USA

"A key strength of this volume is its reflexive and broadly approached understanding of what is critical, which extends to questioning the term itself, and that it poses important questions for further research. I recommend it to scholars in IR and IPE plus those working on social theory and the history of ideas, as well as to postgraduate and PhD students." – Ulrich Brand, University of Vienna, Austria

"'Critical IPE' is commonly criticised as an umbrella term for a head-nodding, self-referential ensemble of Post-Marxists and Post-Structuralists moaning into the void of late capitalism. Shields, Bruff and Macartney correct this depiction and have assembled a range of thoughtful essays, commentaries and polemics to challenge not only the orthodoxy in the field of IPE but also Critical IPE scholars." – Leonard Seabrooke, Copenhagen Business School, Denmark

"A pathbreaking survey of the state of IPE drawing lessons from the past and confronting the challenges of the 21st century." – Anastasia Nesvetailova, City University London, UK

"Theauthors certainly succeed in their aim of providing an overview of critical IPE and, what I appreciate just as much, they are not afraid to 'stress that critical IPE remains contested' trhoughout the book. The book thus serves its task very well to bring critical IPE closer to scholars. One may only hope that empirical research will bbuild on its theoretical rigor." - Tomáš Profant, International Issues & Slovak Foreign Policy Affairs

Editorial Reviews

"Cause for celebration: a 'critical' volume on IPE that is worthy of the name. This innovative text is not only a good read but a crucial contribution at a critical moment. It breaks out of stale boxes and sterile debates, asks silenced questions, takes us in new directions, and gets real about being critical." – V. Spike Peterson, University of Arizona, USA

"A key strength of this volume is its reflexive and broadly approached understanding of what is critical, which extends to questioning the term itself, and that it poses important questions for further research. I recommend it to scholars in IR and IPE plus those working on social theory and the history of ideas, as well as to postgraduate and PhD students." – Ulrich Brand, University of Vienna, Austria

"'Critical IPE' is commonly criticised as an umbrella term for a head-nodding, self-referential ensemble of Post-Marxists and Post-Structuralists moaning into the void of late capitalism. Shields, Bruff and Macartney correct this depiction and have assembled a range of thoughtful essays, commentaries and polemics to challenge not only the orthodoxy in the field of IPE but also Critical IPE scholars." – Leonard Seabrooke, Copenhagen Business School, Denmark

"A pathbreaking survey of the state of IPE drawing lessons from the past and confronting the challenges of the 21st century." – Anastasia Nesvetailova, City University London, UK

"The authors certainly succeed intheir aim of providing an overview of critical IPE and, what I appreciate just as much, they are not afraid to 'stress that critical IPE remains contested' trhoughout the book. The book thus serves its task very well to bring critical IPE closer to scholars. One may only hope that empirical research will bbuild on its theoretical rigor." - Tomáš Profant, International Issues & Slovak Foreign Policy Affairs

From the Publisher