Critique of Rights / Edition 1

by Christoph Menke, Christopher Turner

Overview

Modern political revolutions since the 18th century have swept away traditional systems of domination by declaring that ‘all men are created equal’. This declaration of equal rights is a fundamental political act – it is the political act in which the political community creates itself in relation to traditional systems of domination. But because it was generally assumed that the subject of these rights is the individual human being, the political community was subordinated to the individual. Marx discerned, rightly, that this was the paradox at the heart of the declaration of the rights of man.   But while Marx was right to highlight this paradox, his proposed solution does not provide us with a sound basis for overcoming it.   

In this major new work, Christoph Menke adopts a different approach: he argues that we can address and overcome this paradox only by embarking on a fundamental inquiry into the nature of rights.  Rights are a specific configuration of normativity: to have a right is to have a justified and binding claim.  But with the equal rights declared by modern revolutions, rights assumed a particular form: the normative claim to equality was combined with an assumption about the factual conditions of social life.  In this conception, society is the realm of private individuals pursuing their interests, and private interests are therefore seen as the natural basis for politics – what Menke calls ‘the naturalization of the social’. By laying bare this conception which lies at the basis of political literalism and modern law, Menke is able to criticize and move beyond it, opening up a new way of understanding rights that no longer involves the disempowering of the political community.  

This radical critique of rights and of modern law is a major contribution to critical theory and legal theory and it will be of great interest to students and scholars in social and political theory, philosophy and law.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781509520381
Publisher:	Polity Press
Publication date:	03/09/2020
Pages:	350
Product dimensions:	5.90(w) x 9.00(h) x 1.20(d)

About the Author

Christoph Menke is Professor of Philosophy at the Goethe University, Frankfurt.

Table of Contents

Marx's Puzzle 1

Part I History: The Legalization of the Natural

1 A Philosophical History of Right's Form 9

2 Interest in Self-Preservation 27

3 Inner Choice 43

4 Antagonism of Performance 61

Part II Ontology: The Materialism of Form

5 Legality's Gap 71

6 Materialization 95

7 The Critique of Rights 116

Part III Critique: The Authorization of One's Own

8 Authorization 125

9 Self-Will 140

10 The Privatization of the Public: Two Examples 161

11 Conclusion: The Bourgeois Subject - Loss of Negativity 178

12 Subjective Rights and Social Domination: An Outline 191

Part IV Revolution: The Dialectic of Judgment

13 The Aporia of the Bourgeois Constitution 227

14 Slave Revolt: Critique and Affirmation 243

15 A New Right 267

Law and Violence 292

Notes 295

Index 360