[A]n avuncular, erudite guide to a Who’s Who of Colonial Calvinism’s most influential authors: Bradford, Shepard, Hooker, Winthrop, Cotton, and Morton among them. Colacurcio’s enthusiasm for the works is infectious, and the scope of his study demonstrates his mastery of their works. . . . Less a tightly knit argument than a leisurely stroll through the sensory pleasures of close reading, this book makes a persuasive case for the riches of what can now be legitimately designated ‘Puritan literature.’” —Choice
“[This is] an illuminating and deeply searching compendium that embodies the culmination of a lifelong career in research and teaching. . . . Godly Letters implicitly adopts the matrix of Perry Miller’s New England Mind and asserts that America’s self-definition, politics, and morale are deeply rooted in their puritan beginnings. . . . [A] rare gem, an intellectual feast of the first order.” —The New England Quarterly
“Limiting himself to the ‘big books’ of New England’s founding generation—works of history, cycles of sermons, and autobiographical literature from William Bradford to Roger Williams—Colacurcio nevertheless provides new and often surprising insights to these texts. . . . [A] rich and rewarding work by a scholar whose interpretative instincts and sensitivity to Puritan theological and aesthetic nuance is unrivalled.” —Calvin Theological Journal
“That Godly Letters is a major, remarkable, and extraordinary achievement of intellectual and literary criticism is utterly undeniable; anyone who turns to Puritan literary materials will find Godly Letters indispensable.” —Christianity and Literature
“[Godly Letters] demonstrates throughout a grasp of Puritan theology and psychology both scholarly and empathetic. It is a book full of diligence, perception and even passion.” —Modern Philology
"From a premiere scholar of early American literature, Godly Letters is a masterful study of New England Puritan theology and literature. With wit, humor, and a full command of the scholarship, Colacurcio's analysis of the complex thought and verbal artistry of the writers reveals their remarkable subtlety, intellectual tenacity, and powerful religious convictions, all of which have had a lasting impact on the culture of the United States. This book is a landmark in American Studies research." —Emory Elliott, University of California, Riverside, author of the Cambridge Introduction to Early American Literature
"Michael J. Colacurcio's monumental commentary is a signal contribution to scholarship on early American literature and culture. Colacurcio is the first to present a genuinely comprehensive account of first-generation thought and expression—one that analyzes these writers seriously but critically in their own religious terms. With consummate skill and understanding, Colacurcio achieves this ambitious goal." —John Gatta, University of Connecticut and Sewanee: The University of the South
"Michael Colacurcio is a brilliant reader and a prodigious storyteller. He elucidates the theological, political, economic, and social issues that shaped 'the (not quite canonical) books of New England's first Puritan generation,' revealing what was at stake for these writers, and showing why their narratives are so compelling. Colacurcio's account of John Cotton's debates with his colleagues offers the clearest and subtlest account yet written of the theological complexities underlying the Antinomian Controversy, but also captures the rhetorical energy—and the readerly pleasure—of the ministers' sometimes impatient exchanges. Through readings both witty and sympathetic, Colacurcio reveals the poignancy and the poetry of New England's 'godly letters.'" —Lisa Gordis, Barnard College
