Publishers Weekly
11/30/2020
Historian Picone (The President Is Dead!) provides a copiously detailed account of efforts to memorialize U.S. president and Civil War general Ulysses S. Grant after his death in 1885. The result of those efforts, a 150-foot-tall mausoleum next to Manhattan’s Riverside Park, is “larger than the final resting place of any other person in America,” Picone notes. He documents resentment over the site selection (the Soldiers’ Home in Washington, D.C., was a popular alternative), describes the initial design contest as “an unmitigated disaster,” and tracks the ups and downs of fund-raising efforts. In the years after the memorial was dedicated in 1897, Picone writes, it vied with the Statue of Liberty as the most popular tourist attraction in the city. But rising crime rates and poor maintenance in the 1970s and ’80s made the tomb a “grim poster child for urban decay,” according to Picone, until a National Park Service volunteer’s complaints and a 1994 New York Times editorial helped to galvanize restoration efforts. Picone’s level of detail staggers, and readers with a deep interest in Grant’s legacy and the history of America’s monuments will best appreciate this exhaustive account. (Feb.)
From the Publisher
"Grant’s Tomb is a book to be savored by anyone with an interest in American history. . . . An engrossing look at the fight to memorialize the former president’s final resting place. . . Deeply researched, accessible, and gets to the truth."—Washington Independent Review of Books
"My favorite book this year, as it speaks to the political times we inhabit: Louis L. Picone’s recounting not so much of who’s buried in Grant’s tomb but why the great man rests in an oversized mausoleum in a remote corner of Upper Manhattan."—Bill Whalen, contributing columnist, Washington Post
“I enjoyed no book more than Louis Picone’s Grant’s Tomb . . . Picone describes Grant—oddly caricatured and overlooked today—for the epic figure he truly was . . . [and] effectively deals with the financial hardships that Grant faced after he left the presidency, the writing of those memoirs with publishing help from Mark Twain, and Grant’s courageous battle with his terminal illness.”—Mike Lunsford, Tribune-Star
"Picone’s level of detail staggers, and readers with a deep interest in Grant’s legacy and the history of America’s monuments will best appreciate this exhaustive account."—Publishers Weekly
"This chronicle resonates with contemporary arguments over the role of historical monuments."—Booklist
"A fresh look at the United States figure who made President Abraham Lincoln’s resolve to maintain the union during the Civil War a reality . . . in an era when monuments are being re-evaluated for their significance, political divisiveness seems insurmountable, and individuals feel ineffectual, the story of this monument is in a way a fable for out times."—US1 Princeton Info
"The death of Ulysses S. Grant helped unite a nation still healing from the Civil War, but it also touched off a fascinating and often contentious debate: How best to memorialize the general who saved the Union? In Grant’s Tomb, Louis Picone superbly weaves the somber with the absurd, and brings to vivid life the colorful cast of characters that built the memorial, from titans of industry to children holding bake sales. Grant’s Tomb also examines the memorial’s enduring place in the American psyche, from Groucho Marx to hip hop. At the end, readers will learn that there’s more than one answer to the question. 'Who’s buried in Grant’s Tomb?”—Matthew Algeo, author of Harry Truman's Excellent Adventure
"Sometimes a tomb tells a story all its own. In his moving new book, Louis Picone reveals the fascinating and forgotten tale behind the creation of a memorial befitting Ulysses S. Grant. Like the tomb itself, this book embodies the courage and complexity of a celebrated Civil War hero, flawed former president, and one of history’s most memorable men.”—Candice Millard, New York Times bestselling author of The River of Doubt
“Louis Picone’s fine book is a welcome and timely reminder of how the death of an American hero can serve as a powerful force for reconciliation and reunification after divisive struggle. Picone gives us the broader context with his riveting account of Grant’s struggle in his final days to write his memoirs with the help of Mark Twain and with the enormous outpouring of love for the general who saved the union. We can lament with the author that Grant’s Tomb in Riverside Park in New York is not more appreciated today.“—James Reston, Jr., author of A Rift in the Earth: Art, Memory, and the Fight for a Vietnam War Memorial
"Louis Picone’s Grant’s Tomb offers a well-researched and captivating description of the origins, building, and early decades of New York City’s neoclassical Ulysses S. Grant Monument, as well as its later fall from grace. Readers of this fine book, which is accompanied by striking images, will learn much about the politics and money behind monuments as well as the vagaries of public memory, all set within a story of how a once venerated monument was allowed to deteriorate into a graffiti-tarnished, crumbling pile in the late twentieth century."—Joan Waugh, author of U.S. Grant, American Hero, American Myth
"Grant’s Tomb offers a new generation a compelling way to discover the monument in its many layers, some invisible to visitors except as history. Picone tells with great skill what is at the end of the day a very human story, filled with unexpected twists and turns. He includes much welcome historical and cultural context, besides drawing from his own expertise in the presidency to explain the uniqueness of the story of Grant and his final resting place."—Frank Scaturro, president of the Grant Monument Association and author of President Grant Reconsidered
"Louis Picone has done us all a great service in this readable and richly detailed overview of the most visible yet least-studied aspect of U. S. Grant’s life: his death and burial. Grant’s Tomb was the place where my own awakening, as a descendant and name-bearer of the great general, began. The rise and fall and phoenix-like rebirth of the Tomb embodies the reality of the public’s perception of Ulysses S. Grant over 150 years. Picone not only gives us the facts, but he puts the Tomb, and its occupants, into the fascinating and complicated historical and social context of this country over the past turbulent century."—Ulysses Grant Dietz, great-great-grandson of Ulysses S. Grant
