Disc 1
- Goodbye Sue
- Have I Stayed Away Too Long?
- I Love You
- Long Ago and Far Away
- Lili Marlene
- I Dream of You (More Than You Dream I Do)
- I'm Confessin'
- More and More
- Temptation
- I'm Gonna Love That Gal (Like She's Never Been Loved Before)
- If I Loved You
- Till the End of Time
- That Feeling in the Moonlight
- Dig You Later (A Hubba-Hubba-Hubba)
- Here Comes Heaven Again
- I'm Always Chasing Rainbows
- You Won't Be Satisfied (Until You Break My Heart)
- All Through the Day
- Prisoner of Love
- If You Were the Only Girl
- They Say It's Wonderful
- Surrender
- More Than You Know
- If I'm Lucky
Disc 2
- Winter Wonderland
- That's the Beginning of the End
- Sonata
- When You Were Sweet Sixteen
- Chi Baba Chi Baba (My Bambino Go to Sleep)
- I Wonder Who's Kissing Her Now
- So Far
- Because
- Haunted Heart
- Rambling Rose
- N'yot N'yow (The Pussycat Song)
- Far Away Places
- Blue Room
- Forever and Ever
- I Don't See Me in Your Eyes Anymore
- A-You're Adorable
- Bali Hai
- Some Enchanted Evening
- Just One Way to Say I Love You
- Let's Take an Old Fashioned Walk
- Give Me Your Hand
- A Dreamer's Holiday
- I Wanna Go Home (With You)
- The Lord's Prayer
Disc 3
- Ave Maria
- Bibbity-Bobbity-Boo
- On the Out-Going Tide
- Hoop-Dee-Doo
- I Cross My Fingers
- Patricia
- A Bushel and a Peck
- So Long Sally
- (I Wonder Why) You're Just in Love
- Zing Zing-Zoom Zoom
- If
- Hello Young Lovers
- There's a Big Blue Cloud
- There's No Boat Like a Rowboat
- Rollin' Stone
- With All My Heart and Soul
- It's Beginning to Look Like Christmas
- Tulips and Heather
- Please Mr. Sun
- Noodlin' Rag
- One Little Candle
- Maybe
- Watermelon Weather
- My Love and Devotion
Disc 4
- To Know You Is to Love You
- Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes
- Wild Horses
- I Confess
- My One and Only Heart
- Say You're Mine Again
- No Other Love
- You Alone (Solo Tu)
- Pa-Paya Mama
- Wanted
- Idle Gossip
- Hit and Run Affair
- Papa Loves Mambo
- The Things I Didn't Do
- There's No Place Like Home for the Holidays
- Ko Ko Mo
- Nobody
- Two Lost Souls
- Chee Chee-Oo Chee (Sang the Little Bird)
- Fooled
- Tina Marie
- All at Once You Love Her
- The Rose Tattoo
- Hot Diggity
- Jukebox Baby
- More
Disc 5
- Glendora
- Dream Along With Me
- Somebody Up There Likes Me
- Moonlight Love
- Chincherinchee
- Round and Round
- Mi Casa, Su Casa [My House Is Your House]
- The Girl With the Golden Braids
- My Little Baby
- Dancin'
- Just Born (To Be Your Baby)
- Jingle Bells
- Ivy Rose
- Catch a Falling Star
- Magic Moments
- Kewpie Doll
- Dance Only With Me
- I May Never Pass This Way Again
- Moon Talk
- Love Makes the World Go 'Round
- Mandolins in the Moonlight
- Tomboy
- I Know
- Delaware
- I Know What God Is
- Make Someone Happy
- You're Following Me
- Caterina