OCTOBER 2016 - AudioFile
Ray Panthaki returns to narrate the second in Sands’s series. He reads with precision, highlighting the author’s obvious research and careful detailing. Together, the story and its narration immerse listeners in the horrors of the 1665 London plague. Panthaki’s portrayal of the story’s hero, Christopher, is questioning and thoughtful. Christopher is pensive by nature, but in this sequel the apothecary’s apprentice is coming to grips with his mentor’s death, the struggle to survive, and untangling a cipher that will lead to his mentor’s legacy. Panthaki draws Christopher’s two loyal friends as convincingly as the story’s villains. Tension and confusion mount as two strangers enter the town. Are they healers, prophets, or manipulators? Panthaki’s narration matches the action and adventure in this fast-moving mystery. S.W. © AudioFile 2016, Portland, Maine
School Library Journal
★ 10/01/2016
Gr 4–8—This follow-up to The Blackthorn Key places readers right in the middle of the nastiest event the 1600s had to offer—the Black Plague. Not only are Christopher and his friends tasked with avoiding the deadly disease but they must also contend with the prophets, zealots, and frauds who seem to attach themselves to all tragic events. Sands's writing is gripping and expertly paced. The action spins with breathless twists and turns. The characters react logically without appearing clairvoyant. The deep understanding of herbs, mixtures, and remedies will inspire some and astound others. Christopher and his companions are relatable tweens. This story would make for a great fictional pairing in history class. VERDICT An excellent sequel. Readers who haven't yet discovered this series are in for a treat.—Chad Lane, Tulip Grove Elementary School, MD
OCTOBER 2016 - AudioFile
Ray Panthaki returns to narrate the second in Sands’s series. He reads with precision, highlighting the author’s obvious research and careful detailing. Together, the story and its narration immerse listeners in the horrors of the 1665 London plague. Panthaki’s portrayal of the story’s hero, Christopher, is questioning and thoughtful. Christopher is pensive by nature, but in this sequel the apothecary’s apprentice is coming to grips with his mentor’s death, the struggle to survive, and untangling a cipher that will lead to his mentor’s legacy. Panthaki draws Christopher’s two loyal friends as convincingly as the story’s villains. Tension and confusion mount as two strangers enter the town. Are they healers, prophets, or manipulators? Panthaki’s narration matches the action and adventure in this fast-moving mystery. S.W. © AudioFile 2016, Portland, Maine
Kirkus Reviews
★ 2016-07-02
It is 1665, and the plague has arrived in London, bringing with it prophets of doom and unscrupulous swindlers hoping to prey upon the fears of the desperate citizens. Christopher, former apprentice to the late apothecary Benedict Blackthorn, finds himself at the center of a conspiracy that will end in either a cure for the Black Death or the destruction of society. Melchior, a charismatic prophet, draws followers by predicting where the plague will strike next. The arrival of an unknown apothecary who claims to have the cure increases the frenzy. It is up to Christopher and Tom, the baker’s son, to solve the mystery swirling around both men. Desperate poverty, magical thinking, and a complete disregard for life are everyday realities for those living during the Great Plague of London. And Sands does not shy away from exploring the mesmerizing, gritty, and often terrifying details. However, Christopher and Tom’s friendship, their earnest desire to help others, and their bravery more than make up for the dark reality. The addition of the plucky and fearless Sally provides the perfect balance for the loyal friends. An author’s note offers historical details as well as the shocking revelation that the plague remains a serious threat today. Another stunner proves a worthy sequel to The Blackthorn Key (2015). (Historical mystery. 8-12)