Disc 1
- April Love - Pat Boone
- Sincerely - Alan Freed - Harvey Fuqua - McGuire Sisters
- The Twelfth of Never - Jerry Livingston - Johnny Mathis - Paul Francis Webster
- Happy, Happy Birthday Baby - Tune Weavers
- I'll Never Stop Loving You - Nicholas Brodszky - Sammy Cahn - Doris Day
- Love Me Tender - Elvis Presley
- Kisses Sweeter Than Wine - Jimmie F. Rodgers - Traditional
- My Foolish Heart - Billy Eckstine - Ned Washington - Victor Young
- Why Don't You Believe Me - Patti Page
- With These Hands - Eddie Fisher
- (You've Got) The Magic Touch - Platters
- An Affair to Remember - Vic Damone
- Half a Photograph - Kay Starr
- My Special Angel - Jimmy Duncan - Bobby Helms
- No, Not Much! - Four Lads
- Could This Be Magic - Richard Blandon - Dubs - Hiram Johnson
- A Woman in Love - Four Aces
- You're Just in Love - Perry Como
- Comes A-Long-A-Love - Kay Starr
- I'm Confessin' (That I Love You) - Doc Daugherty - Mary Ford - Al J. Neiburg - Les Paul - Ellis Reynolds
- Love Is Strange - Mickey & Sylvia
- Make Yourself Comfortable - Sarah Vaughan
- Nevertheless (I'm in Love with You) - Mills Brothers
- Party Doll - Buddy Knox
- I'll Always Love You - Ray Evans - Jay Livingston - Dean Martin
Disc 2
- Melody of Love - Billy Vaughn
- My Prayer - Georges Boulanger - Jimmy Kennedy - Platters
- Stranger in Paradise - Tony Bennett - George Forrest
- Would I Love You (Love You, Love You) - Patti Page
- You Send Me - Sam Cooke
- All at Once You Love Her - Perry Como
- Born to Be with You - Chordettes
- Come Go with Me - Del Vikings
- Count Every Star - Ray Anthony - Bruno Coquatrix - Sammy Gallop
- Have I Told You Lately That I Love You - Rick Nelson - Scotty Wiseman
- If I Give My Heart to You - Doris Day
- Just Walking in the Rain - Johnny Bragg - Johnnie Ray - Robert Riley - Lester Stantley
- Little Darlin' - Diamonds
- On the Street Where You Live - Vic Damone - Alan Jay Lerner - Frederick Loewe
- Seven Lonely Days - Georgia Gibbs
- Trying - Hilltoppers - Billy Vaughn
- Band of Gold - Don Cherry
- Can Anyone Explain (No, No, No) - Ames Brothers
- Canadian Sunset - Andy Williams
- Eddie My Love - Teen Queens
- Heart - Eddie Fisher
- Let Me Go Lover - Patti Page
- Peggy Sue - Buddy Holly
- There's No Tomorrow - Leon Carr - Leo Corday - Eduardo DeCapua - Al Hoffman - Tony Martin
- Tonight You Belong to Me - Patience and Prudence
Disc 3
- It's Not for Me to Say - Robert Allen - Johnny Mathis - Al Stillman
- (Now and Then) There's a Fool Such as I - Jo Stafford
- A Kiss to Build a Dream On - Louis Armstrong
- Fascination - Fidenco Dante Marchetti - Jane Morgan
- Friendly Persuasion - Pat Boone - Dimitri Tiomkin - Paul Francis Webster
- Mr. Wonderful - Larry Holofcener - Peggy Lee
- No Other Love - Perry Como
- Something's Gotta Give - McGuire Sisters - Johnny Mercer
- Three Coins in the Fountain - Sammy Cahn - Four Aces - Jule Styne
- Wonderful, Wonderful - Johnny Mathis
- Allegheny Moon - Patti Page
- Love Letters in the Sand - Pat Boone
- Allez-Vous-En - Kay Starr
- Love Me - Elvis Presley
- Darling Je Vous Aime Beaucoup - Nat King Cole - Anna Sosenko
- You Don't Know Me - Jerry Vale
- Bewitched - Mel Torme
- Send for Me - Nat King Cole
- Butterfly - Andy Williams
- Chances Are - Robert Allen - Johnny Mathis - Al Stillman
- Diana - Paul Anka
- Honeycomb - Jimmie Rodgers
- Somewhere Along the Way - Kurt Adams - Nat King Cole - Sammy Gallop
- Young Love - Tab Hunter
- True Love - Bing Crosby - Grace Kelly - Cole Porter