NOVEMBER 2020 - AudioFile
This well-written and beautifully performed story about the French Revolution is seen through the eyes of a young aristocrat. Hélène d’Aubign’s life is recounted in flashbacks as she awaits trial in jail. Narrator Sarah Naughton draws listeners in with her splendid pronunciation of the French phrases scattered throughout this audiobook. Naughton’s most stunning scene is the near rape that occurs after Hélène refuses to marry a man she does not love. The brutal drama and sexual threat Naughton generates may keep listeners awake for hours. Hélène must find her place in the new Paris, and she also must find her true identity. The history is factual, the characters are authentic, and Sarah Naughton is superb. E.E.S. Winner of AudioFile Earphones Award © AudioFile 2020, Portland, Maine
Kirkus Reviews
2020-07-28
A French teen searches for her identity against a backdrop of revolution.
In Paris in the summer of 1792, 19-year-old Hélène d’Aubign, daughter of a French marquis, is thrown into prison—though she doesn’t know who accused her or what her crime is. The story flashes back nine years and recounts her growing up with an idealistic governess, unfeeling mother, and domineering father. Alternately indulged and oppressed, she falls in love with Théo, a jeweler’s apprentice. When villagers kill her father and set fire to the family’s château, Hélène and her mother escape to her mother’s family, whom she’s never met. Hélène begins to unearth family secrets while plotting to return to Théo, but when she manages to reach Paris she is met with news that changes everything. She settles into life as an ordinary citizen, but danger still lurks—brief prison scenes interrupt the narrative until the timelines converge at Hélène’s trial. Bandy’s debut features credible historical detail, an engaging narrator, and a sweet romance. Lulls in the pacing slow momentum, and the ending sacrifices credibility for convenience. Ultimately, this is an above-average history and romance, though less satisfying in terms of the mystery. Major characters are White; Hélène’s radical governess introduces her to her lover, a formerly enslaved Black abolitionist.
A lush portrayal of personal and national struggles let down by a rushed ending. (Historical fiction. 12-18)