Politicizing the International Criminal Court: The Convergence of Politics, Ethics, and Law

by Steven C. Roach

Overview

The establishment of the International Criminal Court (ICC) in July 1998 has attracted growing interest in the evolving role of politics in international law. Steven C. Roach's innovative and systematic work on the political and ethical dimensions of the ICC is the first comprehensive attempt to situate the politics of the ICC both theoretically and practically. Linking the ICC's internal politicization with its formative development, Roach provides a unique understanding of this institution's capacity to play a constructive role in global politics. He argues that an internal form of politicization will allow the ICC to counter outside efforts to politicize it, whether this involves the political agenda of a state hegemon or the geopolitical interests of U. N. Security Council permanent members. Steering a new path between conventional approaches that stress the formal link between legitimacy and legal neutrality, and unconventional approaches that treat legitimacy and politics as inextricable elements of a repressive international legal order, Roach formulates the concept of political legalism, which calls for a self-directed and engaged application of the legal rules and principles of the ICC Statute. Politicizing the International Criminal Court is a must-read for scholars, students, and policymakers interested in the dynamics of this important international institution.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780742541030
Publisher:	Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Publication date:	08/24/2006
Pages:	240
Product dimensions:	6.34(w) x 9.31(h) x 0.91(d)

About the Author

Steven C. Roach is assistant professor in the Department of Government and International Affairs at the University of South Florida. He is the author of Cultural Autonomy, Minority Rights, and Globalization, and editor of Critical Theory and International Relations: A Reader. He has published numerous articles in peer-reviewed journals and is currently finishing a book on the evolution of critical international theory.

Table of Contents

Chapter 1 Introduction: The Global Politics of Criminalizing Violence Part 2 Part I History and Legal Structure Chapter 3 Historical Background: From the League of Nations to the Rome Conference Chapter 4 Legal Principles and Political Issues Part 5 Part II Theory and Ethics Chapter 6 Legalization, Pragmatic Ethics, and Integration Chapter 7 Constructing World Society: The Ethics and Politics of Global Juridification Chapter 8 Value Pluralism and Political Cosmopolitanism Part 9 Part III Political Legalism: Political Strategies and Policy Arrangements Chapter 10 U.S. Opposition and Strategic Accommodation Chapter 11 Religion and Politics: Arab States and the Role of Islamic Ethics Chapter 12 A Cooperative Arrangement with the U.N. Security Council Chapter 13 Conclusion: Toward New Global Political Order

What People are Saying About This

Geoffrey Robertson

Law and politics do not usually mix, but if global justice is to flourish, courts must make some compromises with the 'realpolitik.' This is an important study of an uncomfortable fact of international legal life.

Editorial Reviews

At last social theorists and scientists are taking the International Criminal Court seriously! To those who believe that the ICC can exist distinctly from politics, Steven Roach's insightful and provocative exploration of the Court's relationship to the political will be a wake-up call. That wake-up call, however, has little to do with the pessimism of realpolitik that so dominates the field; it is, instead, an appeal to invest the Court with the right sort of politics—a 'political legalism.'

Frédéric Mégret

Law and politics do not usually mix, but if global justice is to flourish, courts must make some compromises with the 'realpolitik.' This is an important study of an uncomfortable fact of international legal life.

Justice Geoffrey Robertson QC

Certain to frame discussion on the cosmopolitanism of the ICC. .. future researchers will thus want to build on the research of this book.

Perspectives on Politics

Steven Roach poses the important question of what criteria or ends should guide the International Criminal Court when it exercises its potentially broad discretionary jurisdiction. In proposing an answer, he draws creatively on, and attempts in a genuinely interesting way, to marry theories of politics and of international relations. The result is a significant contribution to the theoretical literature on global governance and human rights.

Tom J. Farer

For IR scholars teaching the role of international legalism, Roach's book is very useful and well-pitched core reading.. .. For those seeking to develop a timely interest in the ICC it is both useful and accessible. .. Roach's book remains a valuable addition to our teaching and contextual research resources.

Political Studies Review

Law and politics do not usually mix, but if global justice is to flourish, courts must make some compromises with the 'realpolitik.' This is an important study of an uncomfortable fact of international legal life.--Justice Geoffrey Robertson QC

Steven Roach poses the important question of what criteria or ends should guide the International Criminal Court when it exercises its potentially broad discretionary jurisdiction. In proposing an answer, he draws creatively on, and attempts in a genuinely interesting way, to marry theories of politics and of international relations. The result is a significant contribution to the theoretical literature on global governance and human rights.--Tom J. Farer, University of Denver

At last social theorists and scientists are taking the International Criminal Court seriously! To those who believe that the ICC can exist distinctly from politics, Steven Roach's insightful and provocative exploration of the Court's relationship to the political will be a wake-up call. That wake-up call, however, has little to do with the pessimism of realpolitik that so dominates the field; it is, instead, an appeal to invest the Court with the right sort of politics--a 'political legalism.'--Frédéric Mégret, McGill University

From the Publisher

At last social theorists and scientists are taking the International Criminal Court seriously! To those who believe that the ICC can exist distinctly from politics, Steven Roach's insightful and provocative exploration of the Court's relationship to the political will be a wake-up call. That wake-up call, however, has little to do with the pessimism of realpolitik that so dominates the field; it is, instead, an appeal to invest the Court with the right sort of politics—a 'political legalism.'

Frédéric Mégret

Certain to frame discussion on the cosmopolitanism of the ICC . . . future researchers will thus want to build on the research of this book.

Perspectives On Politics