During the last quarter-century many writers have begun to challenge the legitimacy of the medical profession in general, and psychiatry in particular. Among these are thinkers such as Ivan Illich, Christopher Lasch, Michael Foucault, R.D. Laing, and Thomas Szasz. Although they disagree on some points, they all agree that the medicalization of society in the last 150 years has not improved public health. They concur that Western nation-states have given physicians unwarranted political, social, and moral authority to intervene in our personal lives and the lives of our families. They further maintain that with its growing influence and power, medicine has steadily eroded our autonomy and self-reliance, encouraging us to depend on supposed experts to organize and manage our lives. This dependence on state-employed professionals has left the public vulnerable to state control of those elements in society deemed to be dangerous to the political order and established elites. Critics like Lasch, Illich, Foucault, and Jacques Donzelot conclude that medicine--and especially psychiatry--has been less concerned with the cure of disease than with political control.
