Responding to the Sacred: An Inquiry into the Limits of Rhetoric

by Michael Bernard-Donals (Editor), Kyle Jensen (Editor)

Overview

With language we name and define all things, and by studying our use of language, rhetoricians can provide an account of these things and thus of our lived experience. The concept of the sacred, however, raises the prospect of the existence of phenomena that transcend the human and physical and cannot be expressed fully by language. The sacred thus reveals limitations of rhetoric.

Featuring essays by some of the foremost scholars of rhetoric working today, this wide-ranging collection of theoretical and methodological studies takes seriously the possibility of the sacred and the challenge it poses to rhetorical inquiry. The contributors engage with religious rhetorics—Jewish, Jesuit, Buddhist, pagan—as well as rationalist, scientific, and postmodern rhetorics, studying, for example, divination in the Platonic tradition, Thomas Hobbes’s and Walter Benjamin’s accounts of sacred texts, the uncanny algorithms of Big Data, and Hélène Cixous’s sacred passages and passwords. From these studies, new definitions of the sacred emerge—along with new rhetorical practices for engaging with the sacred.

This book provides insight into the relation of rhetoric and the sacred, showing the capacity of rhetoric to study the ineffable but also shedding light on the boundaries between them.

In addition to the editors, the contributors to this volume include Michelle Ballif, Jean Bessette, Trey Conner, Richard Doyle, David Frank, Daniel M. Gross, Kevin Hamilton, Cynthia Haynes, Steven Mailloux, James R. Martel, Jodie Nicotra, Ned O’Gorman, and Brooke Rollins.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780271089560
Publisher:	Penn State University Press
Publication date:	11/15/2022
Edition description:	Large Print
Pages:	286
Product dimensions:	6.00(w) x 9.00(h) x 0.79(d)

About the Author

Michael Bernard-Donals is Chaim Perelman Professor of Rhetoric and Culture at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. Focusing mainly on the relation between rhetoric and ethics, he has authored or edited ten books in the field.

Kyle Jensen is Professor of English at Arizona State University and the author of Reimagining Process: Online Writing Archives and the Future of Writing Studies.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgements

Introduction: Taking Rhetoric to Its Limits; or, How to Respond to a Sacred Call

Michael Bernard-Donals and Kyle Jensen

Part 1: Sacred Encounters

Sacred Passages, Rhetorical Passwords

Cynthia Haynes

Engaging a Rhetorical God: Developing the Capacities of Mercy and Justice

David Frank

Political Theologies of Sacred Rhetoric

Steven Mailloux

How to Undo Truths with Words: Reading Texts Both Sacred and Profane in Hobbes and Benjamin

James R. Martel

Chanting the Supreme Word of Information: “Sacred?! Redundant?!”

Richard Doyle and Trey Conner

Part 2: Sacred Practices

Hacking the Sacred (or Not): Rhetorical Attunements for Ecodelic Imbrication

Jodie Nicotra

Divining Rhetoric’s Future

Michelle Ballif

Where Is the Nuclear Sovereign?

Ned O’Gorman with Kevin Hamilton

From the Cathedral to the Casino: The Wager as a Response to the Sacred

Brooke Rollins

Rightness in Retrospect: Stonewall and the Sacred Call of Kairos

Jean Bessette

Historiography and the Limits of (Sacred) Rhetoric

Daniel M. Gross

List of Contributors

Index

Editorial Reviews

Responding to the Sacred provides a capacious and prismatic view of communicating that which is not fully communicable, and in doing so, it ventures to rhetoric’s very edges—and beyond.”

—Debra Hawhee,author of Rhetoric in Tooth and Claw: Animals, Language, Sensation

“Each chapter of the book stands out on its own in delving deep into specific themes, while at the same time speaking to the other chapters and the introduction in a holistic manner. Here Bernard-Donals and Jensen’s editorial finesse shows—they weave one narrative while pausing at proper intervals to make space for variegated portals.”

—Ankana Das Reading Religion

From the Publisher