Disc 1

1. A Song for Young Love
2. I'll Be Seeing You
3. Smile
4. It Happened Once Before
5. When I Fall in Love
6. The Way You Look Tonight
7. Come Back Silly Girl
8. Valley High
9. In the Still of the Night
10. Dreamer
11. There's Got to Be a Girl
12. Blueberry Hill
13. Time Was (Duerme)
14. Young and Foolish
15. Lover's Beach
16. Polka Dots and Moonbeams
17. Evening Rain
18. Once Upon a Time
19. How Is Julie
20. My Funny Valentine
21. Remembering Last Summer
22. Sixteen Reasons (Why I Love You)
23. Summer's Gone
24. Turn Around, Look at Me
25. When I Fall in Love [Single Version]
26. That's My Desire
27. Wanted
28. Their Hearts Were Full of Spring
29. When
30. Two Hearts

Disc 2

31. Let It Be Me
32. I Will Love You
33. Love Me Tender
34. Michael
35. Summer's Come and Gone
36. A Tree in the Meadow
37. Silly Boy (She Doesn't Love You)
38. I Told the Stars
39. When You Wish Upon a Star
40. Lonely Little Girl
41. Unchained Melody
42. Again
43. The Whiffenpoof Song
44. Dream
45. Moments to Remember
46. All I Do Is Dream of You
47. Graduation Day
48. No Other Love
49. The Halls of Ivy
50. It's Dark on Observatory Hill
51. Ane Lisle
52. I'll See You in My Dreams
53. The Sweetheart of Sigma Chi
54. The Party's Over
55. Allentown Jail
56. Two Brothers
57. (Son Of) Old Rivers
58. Dutchman's Gold