Unconventional Politics: Nineteenth-Century Women Writers and U.S. Indian Policy

by Janet Dean

Overview

Throughout the nineteenth century, Native and non-Native women writers protested U.S. government actions that threatened indigenous people's existence. The conventional genres they sometimes adopted—the sensationalistic captivity narrative, sentimental Indian lament poetry, didactic assimilation fiction, and the mass-circulated commercial magazine—typically had been used to reinforce the oppressive policies of removal, war, and allotment. But in Unconventional Politics Janet Dean explores how four authors, Sarah Wakefield, Lydia Huntley Sigourney, the Muscogee/Creek S. Alice Callahan, and the Cherokee Ora V. Eddleman, converted these frameworks to serve a politics of dissent. Intervening in current debates in feminist and Native American literary criticism, Dean shows how these women advocated for Native Americans by both politicizing conventional literature and employing literary skill to respond to national policy.

Dean argues that in protesting U.S. Indian policy through popular genres, Wakefield, Sigourney, Callahan, and Eddleman also critiqued cultural protocols and stretched the contours of accepted modes of feminine discourse. Their acts of improvisation and reinvention tell a new story about the development of American women's writing and political expression.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781625342034
Publisher:	University of Massachusetts Press
Publication date:	08/19/2016
Edition description:	First Edition
Pages:	270
Product dimensions:	5.90(w) x 8.90(h) x 0.80(d)
Age Range:	18 Years

About the Author

Janet Dean is professor of English and cultural studies at Bryant University.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments ix

Introduction: Aesthetics, Politics, and Literary Convention 1

1 Nameless Outrages: The Dakota Conflict, Rape Rhetoric, and Sarah Wakefield's "Captivity" Narrative 30

2 "She Wept Alone": The Politics and Poetics of Lydia Sigoumey's Indian Laments 67

3 Reading Lessons: Sentimental Critique in S. Alice Callahan's Wyneina: A Child of the Forest 113

4 Talking Back: Ora Eddleman's 'Indian Magazine" and Native Publicity 152

Epilogue: Toward a Theory of Feminist Indigenist Reinvention 200

Notes 217

Index 249

What People are Saying About This

Cari Carpenter

Unconventional Politics makes a substantial contribution to the field of nineteenth-century literary studies. Specifically, Dean offers a new way of understanding texts both within and in debate with conventions like sentimentality or the captivity narrative.

Siobhan Senier

Dean deftly weaves together scholarship on nineteenth-century American literature, current debates in Native American and Indigenous Studies about the ideological work of literary texts, and theories of literary form and aesthetics. In so doing, she re-places considerations of literary form and aesthetics alongside questions of political and cultural work.

Editorial Reviews

"Dean deftly weaves together scholarship on nineteenth-century American literature, current debates in Native American and Indigenous Studies about the ideological work of literary texts, and theories of literary form and aesthetics. In so doing, she re-places considerations of literary form and aesthetics alongside questions of political and cultural work."—Siobhan Senier, author of Voices of American Indian Assimilation and Resistance: Helen Hunt Jackson, Sarah Winnemucca, and Victoria Howard

"Unconventional Politics makes a substantial contribution to the field of nineteenth-century literary studies. Specifically, Dean offers a new way of understanding texts both within and in debate with conventions like sentimentality or the captivity narrative."—Cari Carpenter, author of Seeing Red: Anger, Sentimentality, and American Indians

"Unconventional Politics eloquently demonstrates the significance and range of its writers and their work, and it exemplifies the value of case studies which calibrate poetics, biography, the social, and the political."—American Literary History

"Dean's writing is focused, detailed, and unrelenting . . . [F]or anyone interested in nineteenth-century protest writing or feminist contributions to Native American studies, this book comes highly recommended."—Native American and Indigenous Studies

"Unconventional Politics considers the boundaries of literary mediums for women's political agendas and urges recovery work to move beyond the politics or aesthetics debate to consider how politics and aesthetics may be present, critiqued, and valued in nineteenth-century women's writing . . . Opens up new avenues for future scholarship in boarding school newspapers and national women's magazines."—Legacy: Journal of American Women Writers

"Dean develops a feminist, cross-cultural, 'Native-centered reading practice' in order to unpack the activism and modes of resistance among her chosen writers."—American Literature

From the Publisher

Unconventional Politics considers the boundaries of literary mediums for women's political agendas and urges recovery work to move beyond the politics or aesthetics debate to consider how politics and aesthetics may be present, critiqued, and valued in nineteenth-century women's writing... Opens up new avenues for future scholarship in boarding school newspapers and national women's magazines.

Legacy: Journal of American Women Writers

Dean's writing is focused, detailed, and unrelenting... [F]or anyone interested in nineteenth-century protest writing or feminist contributions to Native American studies, this book comes highly recommended.

Native American and Indigenous Studies

Unconventional Politics eloquently demonstrates the significance and range of its writers and their work, and it exemplifies the value of case studies which calibrate poetics, biography, the social, and the political.

American Literary History