Publishers Weekly
04/25/2022
“America never would have gotten into this mess if it weren’t for me and my friends,” writes former Republican operative Miller in this anguished yet entertaining exposé of the party’s enthrallment to Donald Trump. Reflecting on his early experiences as a PR consultant and spokesman for John McCain’s 2007 Republican primary campaign, Miller admits that in an era when success “was so often removed from political beliefs,” he “ma allowances” for Republican opposition to gay marriage, despite being a closeted gay man himself at the time. (He’s proud, however, of his role in calling attention to the story that Mitt Romney more than once drove 12 hours with the family dog strapped to the roof of the car.) Comparing the “brainteasers I was playing with my closeted self” to the mental gymnastics of mainstream Republicans who hopped on the Trump bandwagon, Miller also documents the “informal working relationship” he developed with Breitbart cofounder Steve Bannon, despite their “deeply conflicting values and big-picture objectives,” and examines the forces—including House Speaker Paul Ryan’s departure—that pushed congresswoman Elise Stefanik to “take the red pill and open her mind to the great MAGA future.” Witty prose, colorful anecdotes, and copious insider details make this a worthwhile dissection of how Republican “Never Trumpers” got pushed aside. (June)
From the Publisher
Tim is a supremely gifted storyteller who writes with brutal honesty and stylish gallows humor about the GOP’s toxic mix of opportunists, joy riders, and grifters who enabled Donald Trump’s rise and guaranteed his enduring grip on the Republican Party. Tim takes a scalpel to the malignant tumor smothering American democracy by dissecting his own friends and onetime colleagues. The most valuable contribution of Tim’s book may be the anthropological examination of just how little separates a ‘normal’ Republican from an activist working to overthrow a free and fair presidential election. — Nicolle Wallace
Tim’s smart and witty takes on the current madness of our political times has been my balm of Gilead. In this book, Tim examines what makes some people abandon their principles to align with the current center of power and what makes others hold fast to their convictions in spite of finding themselves suddenly on the outs. As a former Republican partisan, Tim breaks it all down in precise bombs of truth and keen insight into some of the more awful truths of human nature when it comes to the allure of power. — Jane Lynch
Mea culpa and tell-all, Tim Miller’s Why We Did It reveals why and how a generation of Republican politicos bent the knee to a president so many of them privately feared and despised. — David Frum
From any dark experience springs something hopeful and good. In the Trump years, that bright side has been Tim and his compatriots who took up arms to fight the MAGA scourge. Before this book, I understood why the crazies and kooks went along with Trump, but now I fully grasp why smart, supposedly ‘normal’ Republicans did, too. Tim’s observations are clear-eyed, wise, brutally honest, and darkly hilarious. Everyone should read this book, especially fellow Democrats who want to better understand our political foes. — James Carville
When the history of this era is written, the dominant question will likely be, How did this happen? Tim Miller’s Why We Did It offers a crucial insider’s answer to that question. It’s a must-read report from the belly of the beast detailing how the unimaginable becomes inevitable. Looking back at a career in politics and being horrified at what you were part of is not the most fun exercise in life. Tim examines his role with clear honesty, sadness, and an amusing sense of the absurd. This is a big, important book. Read it. — Stuart Stevens
Nicolle Wallace
Tim is a supremely gifted storyteller who writes with brutal honesty and stylish gallows humor about the GOP’s toxic mix of opportunists, joy riders, and grifters who enabled Donald Trump’s rise and guaranteed his enduring grip on the Republican Party. Tim takes a scalpel to the malignant tumor smothering American democracy by dissecting his own friends and onetime colleagues. The most valuable contribution of Tim’s book may be the anthropological examination of just how little separates a ‘normal’ Republican from an activist working to overthrow a free and fair presidential election.
Jane Lynch
Tim’s smart and witty takes on the current madness of our political times has been my balm of Gilead. In this book, Tim examines what makes some people abandon their principles to align with the current center of power and what makes others hold fast to their convictions in spite of finding themselves suddenly on the outs. As a former Republican partisan, Tim breaks it all down in precise bombs of truth and keen insight into some of the more awful truths of human nature when it comes to the allure of power.
David Frum
Mea culpa and tell-all, Tim Miller’s Why We Did It reveals why and how a generation of Republican politicos bent the knee to a president so many of them privately feared and despised.
James Carville
From any dark experience springs something hopeful and good. In the Trump years, that bright side has been Tim and his compatriots who took up arms to fight the MAGA scourge. Before this book, I understood why the crazies and kooks went along with Trump, but now I fully grasp why smart, supposedly ‘normal’ Republicans did, too. Tim’s observations are clear-eyed, wise, brutally honest, and darkly hilarious. Everyone should read this book, especially fellow Democrats who want to better understand our political foes.
Stuart Stevens
When the history of this era is written, the dominant question will likely be, How did this happen? Tim Miller’s Why We Did It offers a crucial insider’s answer to that question. It’s a must-read report from the belly of the beast detailing how the unimaginable becomes inevitable. Looking back at a career in politics and being horrified at what you were part of is not the most fun exercise in life. Tim examines his role with clear honesty, sadness, and an amusing sense of the absurd. This is a big, important book. Read it.
Library Journal
01/01/2022
Former Republican political operative Miller, now an MSNBC contributor and Bulwark writer, offers an insider's account of the extremism that has come to define the Republican Party. He places the blame squarely on former friends and colleagues (many interviewed here), whom, he argues, knew exactly what they were doing—inciting a mob for their own gain.
Kirkus Reviews
2022-05-10
A former GOP operative explores possible reasons why so many of his peers fell for Trumpism.
“Why in the fuck did the vast, vast, vast majority of seemingly normal, decent people whom I worked with go along with the most abnormal, indecent of men? And why hadn’t I seen it coming?” So wonders Miller, a communications whiz who locates the demise of the reasonable Republican Party of old in several key events of the last two decades. One was John McCain’s acceding to cynicism in adding Sarah Palin to the ticket—but more, when he pandered to the tea party mob with demands to end immigration from Mexico with his “complete the danged fence” rhetoric, “a nakedly halfhearted version of the Build. The. Wall. chant that was to come.” Numerous other stomach-churning turning points figure in the triumph of Trumpism, aided and abetted by an array of actors: the “LOL Nothing Matters Republicans” who “had decided that if someone like Trump could win, then everything that everyone does in politics is meaningless”; the “Tribalist Trolls” who demanded that nationalist ideas take center stage; and the “Inert Team Players” who couldn’t imagine doing anything apart from being loyal Republicans, so much so that “the idea of being anything besides that is inconceivable.” There were also countless self-serving, self-dealing players who attached themselves to Trump in the hope of taking a share of the big grift. While delivering a carefully argued account of how things went awry, Miller is unsparing in his descriptions of latter-day GOP figures such as Elise Stefanik, who “made a conscious choice to go all-in with her own personal Voldemort because she came to recognize that her popularity, fundraising, and ability to rise within the party would benefit”; and Corey Lewandowski, “a shriveled skin-flute-looking man with no appreciable skills outside of recognizing the popularity of unrestrained Trumpism.”
At once sobering and entertaining, a eulogy for a GOP run amok.
